RESEARCH LIBRARY · TRADE & DIPLOMACY

Trade opens the door.
Relationships carry the work forward.

A conversation about how governments, businesses, and communities turn international connections into economic opportunity.

CSIS & American Academy of Diplomacy · April 11, 2023
Watch the conference Read the transcript

WATCH THE FULL CONVERSATION

Revitalizing American Commercial Diplomacy

The Center for Strategic and International Studies and the American Academy of Diplomacy convened government officials, diplomats, and business leaders to discuss commercial diplomacy and support for U.S. firms overseas. This is a historical 2023 conference, not a statement of present policy.

Conference video: CSIS / American Academy of Diplomacy. Playback is provided by YouTube and may include YouTube controls and links. Read the conference details from CSIS.

WHY THIS MATTERS

A foundation in trade

Opening the event, Bill Reinsch connected commercial diplomacy to the practical need for American firms to reach customers beyond U.S. borders. Under Secretary José W. Fernandez described diplomacy as helping companies compete, build partnerships, and advance commercial transactions.

For the Commercial Diplomacy Index, trade offers a starting point: what a place sells and buys, which markets it reaches, and whether businesses can access opportunity. Relationships, market access, investment, and follow-through can help explain how those opportunities develop.

Trade and market demandRelationships and accessBusiness actionEconomic outcomes
Explore the existing methodology

FROM CONVERSATION TO RESEARCH

Questions to carry into the Index

Trade

What goods and services move between places, and where is demand?

Access

Can businesses find the information, partners, and support needed to enter a market?

Connections

Which institutions and relationships help businesses make and sustain introductions?

Results

What outcomes can be documented over time, with sources and dates clearly identified?

These are research questions, not finalized measures or weights. A transaction or partnership can have many causes; a relationship alone does not establish that diplomacy produced a particular outcome.

FULL PROVIDED TRANSCRIPT

Read the conference conversation

The complete transcript below was supplied with the recording. It appears to be automatically generated and has not been independently verified; names, punctuation, speaker changes, and timestamps may contain errors. Please check the recording before quoting a speaker.

Open the full transcript
Chapter 1: Opening remarks
0:000 secondsemail thank you all for coming I think we've got a a full agenda here through lunch and speaking of lunch
0:077 secondsthere are coffee and pastries outside right now if you want to step out and get some and I hope you're all going to stay for lunch and I hope you're going
0:1616 secondsto stay for the entire morning because I think it's going to be an informative and useful one we're going to be talking about commercial diplomacy which I know
0:2424 secondsmany of you in the room are long time practitioners of or enthusiasts about
0:3131 secondsand we're going to talk about why it matters how the United States is doing on it these days and what we can do to make it
0:4040 secondsbetter so we've got a slight change in the schedule we're going to have two opening comments uh from one from the
0:4848 secondsstate department one from the Commerce Department appropriately and then two panels and then Sean Donnelly and I will
0:5656 secondsdo a very brief wrap up at the end before lunch commercial diplomacy I think I don't need to tell any of you is important
1:051 minute, 5 secondsit's an essential element not only of American Economic Policy when 95 of the world's consumers are outside our
1:131 minute, 13 secondsborders if you want to grow you need to trade it's very simple and it's also I think an element of
1:211 minute, 21 secondsAmerican soft power how we represent ourselves abroad how we remind people of what America can do and what it's uh
1:291 minute, 29 secondswhat it stands for it's part of what we do I have to add there's a personal element of this for me my first boss at the Commerce
1:381 minute, 38 secondsDepartment was Ron Brown who was a practitioner of commercial diplomacy and Jill schuker is here is as well and
1:441 minute, 44 secondsremembers him in fact he died engaging in commercial diplomacy along with a number of members of the private sector
1:521 minute, 52 secondswho had gone with him in this case to Croatia and a lot of friends of ours that we lost so this has significance to
2:002 minutesme I think there's a lot we can do to up our game in commercial diplomacy and today we're going to talk about how to do that so to introduce our keynote
2:092 minutes, 9 secondsfirst I'm going to introduce our our co-sponsor and co-convener of this event the president of the American Academy
2:172 minutes, 17 secondsfor diplomacy Ron Newman who is formerly Deputy assistant Secretary of State and three times as ambassador to all the
2:262 minutes, 26 secondseasy posts Algeria Bahrain and Afghanistan and before that served in Baghdad so you
2:332 minutes, 33 secondsknow this is not somebody who spent his time in you know a non-controversial area knows diplomacy very well so I'm
2:402 minutes, 40 secondsgoing to ask Ron to come up and introduce our speaker and then we'll have I'll introduce our second speaker and then we'll go immediately to the first panel run
Chapter 2: Keynote introduction
2:592 minutes, 59 secondsthat would ruin the show well thank you very much Bill and uh let me start off
3:053 minutes, 5 secondsby saying thanks not only to Bill but to csis our partner in this operation and a
3:133 minutes, 13 secondsspecial thanks to my program director Maria russos and Java who works for Bill without the two of them and and some
3:223 minutes, 22 secondsbackstopping from others including Katie and many others this just wouldn't have come together that you have no idea unless you've done
3:303 minutes, 30 secondsone of these how much goes on to get there so csis and the Academy of diploma America
3:373 minutes, 37 secondsAmerican Academy of diplomacy have been interested involved in working on the subject of commercial diplomacy for
3:453 minutes, 45 secondsquite some years we first did our for a big study about uh eight years ago I think LED jointly
3:533 minutes, 53 secondsby Sean Donnelly and uh former director of foreign commercial service Chuck Ford and
4:014 minutes, 1 secondthat study and there's been a lot of work over here at csis as well it was based on interviews with a large
4:104 minutes, 10 secondsnumber of U.S companies it was not an act sort of academic Pursuit and what we found in that was that there
4:194 minutes, 19 secondswere places where the U.S performed well in supportive business and there were many places where it did not
4:264 minutes, 26 secondsthe performance was uneven and there was a great deal that could be done better now in the intervening years there have
4:354 minutes, 35 secondsbeen improvements I'm sure we'll hear about more uh it's an ongoing process it's one which we very much welcome
4:444 minutes, 44 secondsbut much remains to be done we suggested some changes the champion championing American
4:534 minutes, 53 secondsBusiness through diplomacy kabda Act it was an expression of the
5:005 minutesCongressional restiveness with the support for American Business and the fascinating thing to remember about that act is that it was passed by
5:095 minutes, 9 secondsoverwhelming bipartisan majorities in both houses that was now three years ago and at that point I think it's fair to say that
5:185 minutes, 18 secondsthere was a still a considerable feeling that more needed to be done we'll get some Congressional views later
5:275 minutes, 27 secondswe're very lucky to have Representatives here from all sectors
5:355 minutes, 35 secondsbecause basically commercial diplomacy should be a matter where everyone can agree it's not about doesn't matter what
5:435 minutes, 43 secondsyou think about trade policy or trade agreements or taxes or sanctions it's about selling and winning and that I
5:525 minutes, 52 secondsthink is why there has been so much bipartisan uh agreement we'll have the opportunity to hear multiple points of view today
5:595 minutes, 59 secondsfrom frankly thankfully to under secretary Fernandez starting with state but also with Commerce with a
6:086 minutes, 8 secondscongressional view business and diplomats I hope that it will contribute
6:146 minutes, 14 secondsto increasing and more effective commercial diplomacy something we all want now it's my great pleasure to
6:226 minutes, 22 secondsintroduce secretary under secretary Fernandez who was confirmed by the Senate you know we've refer to him by for short under Secretary of Economics
6:316 minutes, 31 secondsor e but he's actually got this huge portfolio uh you know economic growth energy and the environment uh and he
6:396 minutes, 39 secondshits all the bureaus that do those things but to fill up his spare time he gets to be the United States alternate
6:476 minutes, 47 secondsGovernor to the World Bank the European bank for reconstruction and development the inter-american bank uh so you know
6:546 minutes, 54 secondshe doesn't lack for things to do he served previously as probably many of you in this audience know as the
7:017 minutes, 1 secondassistant secretary for the economy energy and business so he came to his job with an excellent background in both
7:097 minutes, 9 secondsgovernment and business and I'm sure he's drawn on it he was a partner at Gibson Dunn and Crutcher uh where his
7:177 minutes, 17 secondspractice focused on mergers Acquisitions and Finance in Europe again lots of good background uh and then he has Associated
7:257 minutes, 25 secondsinvolved in the work of had quite a slug of associations the American Bar Association the association of the bar
7:327 minutes, 32 secondsof the city of New York New York State Bar Association uh what are you worried about he also recently taught a course on international business transactions
7:417 minutes, 41 secondsanyway I think sufficient to say he comes to us with a great deal of experience a lot of background we're very happy to have you I'm secretary
7:497 minutes, 49 secondsFernandez please
7:527 minutes, 52 seconds[Applause]
Chapter 3: Keynote address
8:008 minutesgood morning good to see a number of people here who uh could teach me a lot about
8:088 minutes, 8 secondseconomic diplomacy and in fact have taught me a lot about economic diplomacy so I'm I'm a little bit embarrassed to
8:168 minutes, 16 secondsuh to be speaking to Ambassador Sakura to a number of you here Tony Wayne and
8:228 minutes, 22 secondsmany others Bill Phil craft so um I think you can you'll you'll let me
8:298 minutes, 29 secondsknow if I've learned my lesson well thank you uh it's it's great to be here it's great to be here at csis and the
8:368 minutes, 36 secondsAmerican Academy of diplomacy uh let me thank you as well uh for inviting me to talk about what I think is a crucial
8:458 minutes, 45 secondstopic of of what we do at the state department and that is looking to uh to work on and improve on on the U.S
8:538 minutes, 53 secondscommercial diplomacy I don't really want to use the term revitalizing I would argue and I realize that it's it's not
9:019 minutes, 1 secondmy title it's your title of the of the conference commercial diplomacy has been long a priority of ours but I'll be the
9:089 minutes, 8 secondsfirst one to agree that it's a constant work in progress that we have to improve
9:159 minutes, 15 secondsI've actually uh oftentimes I will go to uh to Country X and I'll see plain loads of
9:239 minutes, 23 secondsTurkish diplomats and Chinese diplomats and others and they're all accompanied by by business people
9:329 minutes, 32 secondsI'll never forget being in Algeria of all places and seeing two plane loads of of Turkish diplomats and right behind
9:419 minutes, 41 secondsthem for about 200 300 business people and they were there to do deals it was not about philosophy it was about
9:489 minutes, 48 secondsgetting getting transactions done but I um I will tell you this is a priority and uh and if you take anything away
9:579 minutes, 57 secondsit's it's that we are working hard at it and we're trying to get better uh and this is part of why I wanted to be here
10:0410 minutes, 4 secondstoday I think that our efforts have historically enabled us to uh to promote American economic interests and also to
10:1310 minutes, 13 secondscreate mutually beneficial Partnerships the fact of the matter is that we're a global economic Hub and we we continue
10:2110 minutes, 21 secondsto be well positioned to Leverage The Innovation and Leadership of the US in technology and and with our private
10:2910 minutes, 29 secondssector I think we can we can achieve success but this is something we continue to work on every day
10:3710 minutes, 37 secondsU.S commercial diplomacy including at our embassies has to continue to adapt and respond to the significant
10:4510 minutes, 45 secondschallenges in promoting businesses abroad these are challenges that include increased competition from other countries information Technologies rapid
10:5410 minutes, 54 secondsEvolution shifting International Investment climates International tensions and the need to
11:0111 minutes, 1 secondreinforce the connections between commercial diplomacy and foreign policy we recognize that to strengthen U.S
11:1011 minutes, 10 secondseconomic diplomacy we we have to prioritize it we have to prioritize it within our foreign policy and we have to
11:1711 minutes, 17 secondsprovide our diplomats with the resources and the training that they need to to be effective if we do that I think we'll be
11:2611 minutes, 26 secondssuccessful and that's what we try to do I always often find that my counterparts aren't really interested in talking
11:3411 minutes, 34 secondsgeopolitics or talking about they're more interested in talking about how we get transactions across the table
11:4211 minutes, 42 secondsum we we are working with businesses to identify their needs and provide them with the tools to compete effectively in
11:5011 minutes, 50 secondsforeign markets and we are going to continue to work with our partners and allies on on these matters and talk to
11:5711 minutes, 57 secondsour partners and allies about commercial transactions and what we can do together not only because it's the right thing to
12:0412 minutes, 4 secondsdo but because it's in our national interest I think we're actually making progress and I've been in this job for about a year and a half and I see the
12:1212 minutes, 12 secondsImprovement already we've taken a an aggressive set of actions to modernize commercial diplomacy and to place it at
12:2012 minutes, 20 secondsthe heart of our foreign policy just to give you a couple of examples we've established the regional technology
12:2712 minutes, 27 secondsofficer program which places Foreign Service offices wholly focused on wholly focused and critical and emerging
12:3412 minutes, 34 secondsTechnologies in global technology hubs around the world these are specialized officers uh
12:4212 minutes, 42 secondsbuild networks with Innovation communities to include startups Venture capitalists and they also work closely
12:4912 minutes, 49 secondswith officers in promoting U.S Innovation leadership you're also and and Ron mentioned that the uh the
12:5712 minutes, 57 secondschampion American Business through diplomacy act Capital that was signed into law in 2019 it reaffirms the state
13:0413 minutes, 4 secondsDepartment's role in promoting U.S commercial interests around the world and provides us with the tools that we need to compete in the global
13:1313 minutes, 13 secondsMarketplace and we are working together with ustr and with the Commerce Department to uh to lay out our
13:2013 minutes, 20 secondspartnership and to improve our partnership and and you will see a uh a a an economic diplomacy action group
13:2913 minutes, 29 secondsthat we're creating to coordinate our whole of government approach to supporting U.S economic and businesses interests abroad
13:3813 minutes, 38 secondsum the uh the bureau that I was here and that I was privileged to work with a number of you here in this room
13:4613 minutes, 46 secondsum a dozen years ago uh EB is part of a broader uh under
13:5413 minutes, 54 secondsSecretariat that I now lead and it's been closely coordinating with the secretary's offices on his modernization
14:0114 minutes, 1 secondnot modernization agenda to ensure that we have the tools the resources and the processes to help us companies compete
14:0914 minutes, 9 secondsand win deals and I think the some of these efforts are already beginning to bear fruit last year we had 15
14:1514 minutes, 15 secondscommercial deals that we advanced in in CBA one of our offices that were worth
14:2214 minutes, 22 secondsover 89 billion dollars and we did this in close partnership with commerce's Advocacy Center on the defense side we
14:3114 minutes, 31 secondswe helped to generate 17 deals worth over 11 billion dollars in U.S export content and these are
14:3914 minutes, 39 secondssuccesses that we believe have the potential to create hundreds of thousands of well-paying jobs and communities across America
14:4914 minutes, 49 secondsum many of these programs are going to continue to revolve and we we set up for example something called direct line When I Was Here a dozen years ago I took
14:5914 minutes, 59 secondsthe great name for what's really a very basic program and that it started out as a conference call you put ambassadors uh on the phone and you put U.S companies
15:0815 minutes, 8 secondsthat had questions and and wanted help and and it was quite successful and we continue to do that uh in in one example
15:1515 minutes, 15 secondsthough we are now using direct line to incorporate new types of communications uh and and we're
15:2315 minutes, 23 secondsincreasingly focused on new sectors sectors such as critical minerals Communications networks a lot on
15:3115 minutes, 31 secondsrenewable energy on infrastructure development and there's always there's always interest in in having direct line
15:3815 minutes, 38 secondsprograms internally we are working closely with our friends at Commerce to improve support for our Embassy deals
15:4615 minutes, 46 secondsteams these These Are teams that are comprised of State economic officers from former foreign commercial officers
15:5315 minutes, 53 secondsand members of other agencies and they work directly with our companies that are at our overseas embassies and and we
16:0116 minutes, 1 secondare at the same time with these deals and with these transactions once a month at least we have sessions
16:1016 minutes, 10 secondswhere we analyze what we did right what we did wrong and how we can improve and this is something we continue to do again because this is a a work in
16:1916 minutes, 19 secondsprogress and we need to hone our our tactics uh in order to achieve successful advocacy we're doing a lot of commercial
16:2716 minutes, 27 secondsdiplomacy uh these days involving Ukraine commercial diplomacy is also an increasingly important component of our
16:3516 minutes, 35 secondssupport for Ukraine as we help promote the country's economic resilience in the face of a brutal Invasion
16:4416 minutes, 44 secondswe are committed to helping Ukraine recover and build the prosperous and Democratic future and U.S companies are
16:5216 minutes, 52 secondskey Partners in this effort and they are they've remained engaged and and they're playing an important role in keeping the
16:5916 minutes, 59 secondsUkrainian economy afloat enabling local businesses to continue operating we're also looking towards a future the future
17:0817 minutes, 8 secondsof Ukraine the recovery of Ukraine speaking with the U.S companies about what reforms would be helpful to improve
17:1517 minutes, 15 secondsthe investment climate in the post-war environment and that's an important dialogue that we have with the Ukrainian
17:2317 minutes, 23 secondsofficials I had one again yesterday with the Central Bank governor of of Ukraine
17:3017 minutes, 30 secondsand we we talk about what what is it that we can do once it's this brutal Invasion fails in fact on Thursday I'll
17:4017 minutes, 40 secondsbe um I'll be privileged to participate in a high-level Gathering of our interagency partners the U.S private sector and and the government of Ukraine
17:4917 minutes, 49 secondsthat a conference hosted by the by the Chamber of Commerce on how and what conditions will be required to expand
17:5617 minutes, 56 secondsU.S private sector engagement in Ukraine one of the things that is clear in in my conversations
18:0418 minutes, 4 secondswith the Ukrainian officials is that after the war Ukraine will unfortunately have to be a construction site and there'll be a lot of rebuilding to
18:1218 minutes, 12 secondsbe done and that's uh that's a role it's a business opportunity for uh for our companies but it's also strategic
18:2018 minutes, 20 secondsimperative as we move forward so um you know I in short I can confidently
18:2718 minutes, 27 secondsuh report to you that uh U.S commercial diplomacy is Alive and Well in at the state department and not only
18:3518 minutes, 35 secondsremains a priority today for me but it it's something that we continue to work on as we try to meet tomorrow's
18:4218 minutes, 42 secondschallenges we can get better we can get better and we we will we're always trying to improve and you can be sure
18:4918 minutes, 49 secondsthat we will always always work aggressively to ensure that American businesses that are bureaus that are economic officers at the state
18:5718 minutes, 57 secondsdepartment and the nearly 200 missions abroad and that's part of our competitive Advantage at state that we have the resources and the tools that
19:0619 minutes, 6 secondsthat we need to compete with the right policies in place we will ensure that the U.S remains at the Forefront of
19:1319 minutes, 13 secondsinternational business for years to come thank you and have a great conference
Chapter 4: Commerce Department update
19:2319 minutes, 23 secondsforeign
19:3419 minutes, 34 secondsthank you very much that was a great way to start off and now we're going to hear from the Commerce department for those
19:4319 minutes, 43 secondsof you that have the agenda in the room here uh He's listed as a panelist on the second panel but he's gotten an upgrade
19:5019 minutes, 50 secondswhich happens not only in Airlines but here at csis uh Dale tasharsky is a deputy director general of the U.S
19:5719 minutes, 57 secondsforeign U.S and foreign commercial service you think I would know how to say it after all these years
20:0420 minutes, 4 secondshe manages a network of more than 225 domestic and overseas trade offices and a staff of more than 100 1450 trade
20:1320 minutes, 13 secondsprofessionals what you may not know actually when I was surprised to learn is that the foreign commercial service has people
20:2020 minutes, 20 secondsall over the United States and a variety of State offices I learned about working for Senator Rockefeller and we had somebody in West Virginia who wanted to
20:2920 minutes, 29 secondssell things to Ukraine as it happened and we ended up having a good relationship with the the uh our our our
20:3720 minutes, 37 secondsWest Virginia's foreign commercial service officer at the time so they're not they're oriented towards uh exports and selling
20:4620 minutes, 46 secondsbut they exist here in the United States to help American companies that are here particularly small and medium-sized Enterprises figure out how to do things
20:5420 minutes, 54 secondsabroad Dale previously was the deputy assistant secretary for Europe he's a career senior Foreign Service Officer with the
21:0221 minutes, 2 secondsranking Minister counselor who has served all over the place Berlin New Delhi Dublin
21:1021 minutes, 10 secondsTokyo Warsaw Etc so he's got a great depth of knowledge and experience when he finishes remarks if there's time
21:1821 minutes, 18 secondshe's going to take a few questions if you're in the room and have a question there's a standing mic right over here please go over to the mic and stand and
21:2721 minutes, 27 secondswe'll go in order for those of you that are online there is a QR code here that and you can put your question in there
21:3621 minutes, 36 secondsand we'll see if we can figure out how to ask it so Dale all yours foreign
21:4321 minutes, 43 seconds[Applause]
Chapter 5: Commerce Dept. remarks
21:4721 minutes, 47 secondsthank you Bill good morning everyone uh it's Delight to be here and it's Delight to have an upgrade this morning yeah that's always always nice on a Tuesday
21:5421 minutes, 54 secondsmorning let me thank first of all the American Academy for uh hosting this uh this program uh on Commercial diplomacy
22:0022 minutesof course our friends at csis as well um uh it's a it's a delight to to follow under secretary Fernandez and on behalf
22:0822 minutes, 8 secondsof our under secretary Marissa Lago and our assistant secretary uh Arun Adventure common uh I'm I'm very delighted to be with you this morning
22:1622 minutes, 16 secondsjust to give you a couple of uh a couple of thoughts as we uh as we start the day from the Commerce Department's perspective uh as uh as Bill alluded we
22:2422 minutes, 24 secondsare a U.S and foreign commercial service we have about 250 uh staff across the United States in in 48 states
22:3122 minutes, 31 secondsrepresenting all 50. uh and uh and and an additional 250 commercial officers at 120 embassies and consulates around the
22:4022 minutes, 40 secondsworld uh in support of those officers in support of our companies we have another 650 locally engaged staff that will work with us at those posts as well of course
22:4922 minutes, 49 secondswe have a core component here in Washington DC that that focuses on on Regional uh trade policy and and support
22:5622 minutes, 56 secondsof our offices overseas as well as as well as our our leadership here in uh in in Washington DC
23:0423 minutes, 4 secondsum what I would tell you in terms of what we have accomplished over the last year uh are U.S and foreign commercial service which also has by the way a
23:1323 minutes, 13 secondscomponent for inward investment called select USA many of you are are familiar with that and we also run the interagency uh uh advocacy Advocacy
23:2223 minutes, 22 secondsCenter uh for uh for advocating for U.S companies that are that are trying to compete for foreign government tenders uh and uh and I see and as I'm looking
23:3023 minutes, 30 secondsout here as I'm looking around I see a lot of colleagues uh from Posts and I've worked with and of course ambassadors and and distinguished guests it's just great to uh great to see you all here
23:3823 minutes, 38 secondsthis morning we are uh approximately 51 000 U.S companies last year uh receive support from us which which is was an
23:4723 minutes, 47 secondsall-time record for us we're usually average around 30 to 35 000 with technology has helped us reach out to more I think the pandemic helped us find
23:5623 minutes, 56 secondsa new way to approach uh approach business as well so we were delighted to uh to grow our our client base and we refer to U.S companies as our clients
24:0424 minutes, 4 secondsmuch like a consulting firm might uh because we're going to support them in in in whatever they're trying to accomplish either in exporting overseas
24:1224 minutes, 12 secondsor if they are established overseas uh in in helping them uh with Market access issues and things along those lines we
24:1924 minutes, 19 secondsalso I would say uh in terms of numbers of of dollar value about 95 billion dollars of U.S exports and inward
24:2724 minutes, 27 secondsinvestment last year from those companies with small to medium size uh is our uh is kind of our Forte uh 85 to
24:3424 minutes, 34 seconds86 percent actually of our clients last year of those 51 000 were were small to medium-sized companies so when you see
24:4224 minutes, 42 seconds95 billion uh it doesn't make it sound like a lot for for a Year's work but a lot of them are very small company is that that we're getting some things done a couple of big ones in there too but uh
24:5024 minutes, 50 secondsand annual advocacy plays a a key role particularly in the defense sector for some of the big ticket items that I think both state and commerce uh will
24:5824 minutes, 58 secondswork on uh we um uh bring about 350 dollars uh back to the economy for every dollar that's appropriated to us we're
25:0625 minutes, 6 secondsalways you know always interested in in additional Appropriations and we've been working on that uh over the last couple of years and have snuck forward a little
25:1425 minutes, 14 secondsbit uh and we're looking forward to to see how that how that plays out in the uh in the months ahead for uh fiscal year 25 in particular but and that
25:2325 minutes, 23 secondsallows us then to grow staff and put people in in places where we you know where we aren't located right now we're in about 95 percent of the global uh
25:3025 minutes, 30 secondsglobal economy Global uh uh the the GMP uh GDP and we're also 97 percent of
25:3725 minutes, 37 secondsmarkets where U.S companies are are doing business so there's a few places we need to go and and where we're not represented in some of those smaller markets we have our colleagues at the
25:4525 minutes, 45 secondsstate department through our partnership post program that that work work with us in those markets delivering Commerce Department Services in particular to
25:5425 minutes, 54 secondshelp us companies and we do matchmaking we do background checks we do lots of things for for us business uh it's about 25 different things across our our menu
26:0226 minutes, 2 secondsif you will of services that we can we can offer um what I what I just want to touch on before I before I conclude is is something that uh under secretary
26:1026 minutes, 10 secondsFernandez referred to and that is the relationship between Commerce and State uh which I think over these last couple of years has has increased uh uh
26:1826 minutes, 18 secondssignificantly in the areas of commercial diplomacy and of economic diplomacy in Canada and I know many of you were involved in in in pushing that
26:2726 minutes, 27 secondslegislation forward and helping helping craft it uh I think it was really important uh from where I sit uh to uh to to establishing a better relationship
26:3626 minutes, 36 secondsnot only calling uh you know the US government out and saying you got to do more for U.S business uh but uh but also but also bringing us together in a way
26:4426 minutes, 44 secondsthat's going to let us regardless of resources let us kind of work with each other to to expand on the value that we that we can bring and kabda has done
26:5326 minutes, 53 secondsthat and and uh I would say that uh where you know where where our offices in the foreign commercial service and the U.S and foreign commercial service
26:5926 minutes, 59 secondswould be uh uh interlocuting with with the state department our state department colleagues in the economic Bureau in EB uh you know on a weekly or
27:0727 minutes, 7 secondsmonthly basis uh once in a while when issues came up we're not working on a daily basis we actually contact each other and are working on issues on a
27:1527 minutes, 15 secondsdaily basis and that's been going on for the last six to eight months uh and that is because cap does helped move us forward and helped us reshape the way
27:2227 minutes, 22 secondswe're thinking that we can support U.S business from a whole of government a whole of government approach um the the under secretary referred to
27:3027 minutes, 30 secondsthe economic diplomacy Action Group edag uh for short uh you know we like uh as you as we all know we all like our our
27:3827 minutes, 38 secondsacronyms but uh edag is is really important it's a it's a subset of kabda uh that allows us to uh to determine how
27:4527 minutes, 45 secondsbest to to support companies through trade related capacity building and technical assistance in particular so if
27:5327 minutes, 53 secondsyou look at at economic diplomacy and Commercial diplomacy they really we sometimes we kind of cross over and we're talking about one or the other
28:0128 minutes, 1 secondwe're not always entirely sure you know what aspect of it is the reality is is we want to help U.S companies from the get-go whether they're in the U.S field
28:0828 minutes, 8 secondsin our field in in the United States to get them into markets uh where they can where they can do business and where they can grow those markets and help the countries out and help their their
28:1728 minutes, 17 secondsbottom line in creating jobs back home and to do that you've got to have economic and Commercial diplomacy and as we're looking at this under this under
28:2428 minutes, 24 secondsthis e-dag where we will have have a eventually an executive order that establishes this I think if we're in the in the in the in the weeks ahead we're
28:3128 minutes, 31 secondslooking at an opportunity now to uh uh to take uh trade related capacity building on the front end and technical assistance on the front end to build
28:4028 minutes, 40 secondsthose markets that aren't quite ready perhaps for for U.S business where U.S companies would look at them say you know it's a great opportunity but you
28:4828 minutes, 48 secondsknow I've got other opportunities that can make me more money you know over here over there right it's all about competition and so when you're looking at at a development in these markets you
28:5628 minutes, 56 secondshave to have that technical assistance and support on the front end to create a playing field that's going to be competitive for U.S companies where they
29:0329 minutes, 3 secondscan compete fairly uh and that and this this Economic Development piece this economic diplomacy piece that goes into that is very very important and then
29:1129 minutes, 11 secondscommercial diplomacy on the on the continuing spectrum of that is where we're looking at Market access once the market is ready to go you can you have
29:1829 minutes, 18 secondsaccess issues to get in trade barriers other kinds of things that get in the way or perhaps or maybe a lack of understanding of what opportunity communities are that will get in the way
29:2729 minutes, 27 secondsof companies actually establishing themselves and beyond that is the promotion of U.S business in those markets so you take the capacity building aspects and the technical
29:3529 minutes, 35 secondsassistance aspects you take the market access aspects and the and the promotion aspects of business you bring them together under cabin under edag and we
29:4429 minutes, 44 secondshave a great we have a great really sort of template for how the US government is working on a daily basis now as I said to help us company help get our heads
29:5229 minutes, 52 secondsaround how we can help you as companies and then getting that information out to our out to our fields at our in our embassies and consulates around the world
30:0030 minutesum uh the under secretary mentioned a couple things deal teams uh is a is a what we're looking at is a a sort of a field driven support of U.S companies
30:0830 minutes, 8 secondstrying to get deals across the line uh whether they be an investment side or export side whatever the case might be advocacy we have been working hard with
30:1630 minutes, 16 secondsState on recrafting how best to to to to help our our teams around the world understand the resources that are available to them under cabinet when you
30:2530 minutes, 25 secondshave ustr Commerce and state sort of leading the leading the economic diplomacy Action Group you also have the DFC Exxon bank and others who are who are part of
30:3330 minutes, 33 secondsthat part of that discussion and so the idea is to bring as much as we can from Washington to our our colleagues around the world to give them the tools that
30:4030 minutes, 40 secondsthey need in order to do in order to help companies on the ground and in real time get deals across the line and we're working on Deal teams in a big way we've
30:4930 minutes, 49 secondsbeen doing something uh almost quarterly now it's actually more than quarters every other month uh which has been a something called an anatomy of a deal
30:5630 minutes, 56 secondsteam it's an internal review of successes that we've had with U.S companies so that our comp that our our colleagues can talk to each other
31:0431 minutes, 4 secondseverybody gets on from around the world we look at a region we look at a deal that was done we talk about how we did it and what we learned and how we can
31:1131 minutes, 11 secondshow we can you know help the next the next company out uh in doing in doing deals so it's a great way for us to train ourselves uh not only in in things
31:1931 minutes, 19 secondsthat we've done but also in a collaborative nature of what we do together and that collaboration really is something I think was special under
31:2631 minutes, 26 secondsunder cabinets really forced in a way something that we've always had we've had it a lot as my colleagues who served overseas now uh we we have a lot of
31:3531 minutes, 35 secondscollaboration at our posts it's it really works really really well what we need to do is ensure that that collaboration is consistent and that's
31:4231 minutes, 42 secondspart of the reason for captive and that we're getting that type of support and that Washington can help out right and we can give the things that we can that they need to to to to do their business
31:5031 minutes, 50 secondsand that collaboration in and of itself has brought us together we are reinstituting something called the Benjamin Joy award which we haven't done in a couple of years but we're
31:5831 minutes, 58 secondsemphasizing the collaborative aspects of commercial officers and econ officers and political officers and other peoples at the missions working together on
32:0732 minutes, 7 secondsbehalf of on behalf of business it's not just about the deal at the end of the day for us to be really good at this we have to look at ourselves and say how
32:1532 minutes, 15 secondsare we working together what are the aspects what are we doing to create that impact and that's something that uh that we're working on very closely with with
32:2232 minutes, 22 secondsour colleagues there um last last thing I would say training we're working on training as well moving forward Commerce and state you know econ
32:3032 minutes, 30 secondscommercial working together sharing best practices finding new ways to be supportive looking at the tools we have in uh we have at our disposal uh the
32:3932 minutes, 39 secondsunder secretary you know referenced something that I've seen as well and we talked to to companies or to governments around the world they say where are the
32:4632 minutes, 46 secondsU.S companies where is the business you know we've got delegations from China we've got delegations from you know from Europe we've got delegations for what we don't see the U.S companies we've got to
32:5432 minutes, 54 secondschange that we've got we've lost a lot of market share including in our backyard here in the in the Western Hemisphere we've got to change that and I think we're going to be changing that through initiatives like this so I want
33:0333 minutes, 3 secondsto applaud those who helped with getting that legislation across because Canada is really going to be really good for uh for U.S business uh in the long run
33:1133 minutes, 11 secondsthere's a lot of work to do still but we've got some good momentum going we've got a lot of bright bright Minds working on it and I'm really excited about that and of course we've got boots on the
33:1933 minutes, 19 secondsground when you combine the resources the economic sections of the U.S embassies with our commercial sections and that that economic diplomacy and Commercial diplomacy it's going to be a
33:2733 minutes, 27 secondsgood thing for U.S business so I'll stop there and say thank you very much and have a have a great a great afternoon I'm going to stick around and listen to
33:3433 minutes, 34 secondsthe discussions looking forward to it foreign
33:4033 minutes, 40 seconds[Applause]
Chapter 6: Q&A session
33:4833 minutes, 48 secondsnice to see you again as you know uh Chuck Ford your former colleague and I sort of got the academy started on this
33:5533 minutes, 55 secondsuh process and I appreciate your comments could you just talk a little bit about resources budgets numbers of
34:0234 minutes, 2 secondsFCS officers I mean you periodically see articles in the press that make it sound like they're including yesterday yeah
34:0934 minutes, 9 secondsexactly so could you just talk about how priorities are one thing one of the ways you show priority is by how you allocate
34:1734 minutes, 17 secondsresources and how uh you know what's happened uh how are we today compared to how we were X number of years ago thanks
34:2534 minutes, 25 secondsyeah I know Sean thanks so much and and uh it's good to see you again uh you know it's it's always a tricky tricky subject you know in in a public in a public format let's talk about you know
34:3434 minutes, 34 secondsresources and things you need but if you read the political political article yesterday that referred to uh uh the commercial service the foreign foreign
34:4134 minutes, 41 secondscommercial service and the number of staff that we have and and that we're we just don't have enough uh in not only in in Commerce I think in state as well we are we both uh both of our departments
34:5034 minutes, 50 secondshave gotten a little bit of money States gotten uh I think a good a good chunk for for additional uh economic uh uh resources we have gotten you know we
34:5834 minutes, 58 secondshope for more uh we get we take what we can get but we've done well this last year I think we're going to do well uh uh going into 25 as well we've got a
35:0635 minutes, 6 secondsplan folks I mean there's no question we have a Five-Year Plan uh within Global markets which is our parents group here which includes our our former Market
35:1435 minutes, 14 secondsaccess group that was put together with the commercial service we've got a plan for for growth that uh that will create additional uh not only additional
35:2235 minutes, 22 secondspositions at our embassies and and consulates where we where we do business uh but also some uh we're going to open some new offices as well last year uh uh
35:3135 minutes, 31 secondsusing uh some of the resources that we've received we were able to open Bangladesh which is a hot market for us formerly a partnership post for us many of you may have served there uh some of
35:3935 minutes, 39 secondsyou may have been through uh and we're excited about that uh because that's uh that that's a big market for U.S business there are others down the line
35:4635 minutes, 46 secondsuh I can tell you that without without you know being able to tell you exactly where that we are actively uh looking at uh at some additional posts right now
35:5535 minutes, 55 secondsopening some additional posts with the resources we were able to receive uh for 23. uh and in addition uh focusing on on
36:0236 minutes, 2 secondsincreasing our staffing our capacity uh in in key markets particularly in Asia uh you know many of you have heard of the uh the indo-pacific economic
36:1036 minutes, 10 secondsframework uh there are there are countries there that we need to we need to be sure we're paying attention to we also have the partnership for uh Global
36:1736 minutes, 17 secondsinfrastructure and uh you know for uh which is important for us to uh to put people in places where we can take
36:2436 minutes, 24 secondsadvantage and really scope out the opportunities for U.S companies so it's looking pretty good uh it's looking pretty good I'm I'm looking forward to 25. I always have I'm you know my
36:3336 minutes, 33 secondscolleagues will know I'm an optimist I always look into the at the higher number we always you know kind of you know get things get sliced down a little bit but we're we're doing okay I would
36:4036 minutes, 40 secondslove to see us grow I mean we do need more people the more we have the more the better I think you know econ commercial uh you know in in spite of that our ability to work together in a
36:4936 minutes, 49 secondsbit in a in a greater in a greater way in a more strategic way is going to pay off for us as well oops
36:5636 minutes, 56 secondsah sure uh let me put my glasses on
37:1537 minutes, 15 secondsyeah I mean I'm not sure I understand the context of the question the two the two questions are are if they're related
37:2137 minutes, 21 secondssustainable practices in terms of uh uh in in terms of taking initiatives forward on things like climate change uh
37:2937 minutes, 29 secondsyou know on on on on on Tech uh you know for the future there is an emphasis uh through Administration priorities uh in
37:3637 minutes, 36 secondsthese in these areas and and the the the the way to sustain them is is is at least from our perspective is is through our strategic planning uh you know that
37:4437 minutes, 44 secondswe do not only a Commerce but with State uh to ensure that we're we're that we're focusing our our companies uh on opportunities that fit into some of
37:5237 minutes, 52 secondsthese spaces like climate uh like Tech like healthcare and things like that I'm not sure I'm not sure I answered the gentleman's question but uh
38:0138 minutes, 1 secondare there other questions hey Dale thanks very much for the update very encouraging so there's been a lot of attention of
38:0938 minutes, 9 secondscourse to strengthening our internal capacity to manufacture to build to do other things
38:1638 minutes, 16 secondsand it it seems there's been a bit less attention to encouraging our posts overseas
38:2338 minutes, 23 secondsto do the kind of very important work that you just talked about could you say a little bit our ambassadors and the teams getting regular uh indications
38:3338 minutes, 33 secondsthat this is an important thing and that they're going they're going to be looked at for how well they're doing here one of the things in capta is to be a yearly
38:4038 minutes, 40 secondsreport from each mission on the kind of work that both commercial Nikon section are doing together at the mission right that's a great question thank you and I
38:4838 minutes, 48 secondscan I mean reporting of course is the for a commercial person for a Commerce Department person Craig I see uh the Ambassador uh out there we're uh you
38:5738 minutes, 57 secondsknow it's the band of our existence we just like doing things we like to do you know uh but but reporting is important and there is there is a uh there is an
39:0539 minutes, 5 secondseffort particularly in the deal team side to ensure that our their embassies and consulates that the chief of mission uh you know is the you know is the
39:1339 minutes, 13 secondschairman of that uh of that uh deal team uh if you will so we're constantly working at ensuring and I think EB has
39:2039 minutes, 20 secondsdone a good job and CBA have done a good job at this at the state department to encourage ambassadors to say hey look you guys are in charge of this you know and and we'll we'll all fall into line
39:2939 minutes, 29 secondsand whether it's a you know whether it's an econ commercial team supporting an ambassador's view on something or whether it's one or the other leading it
39:3639 minutes, 36 secondsit doesn't really matter we do you do need I think the point that you made is you do need chief of mission focus and I think there's a lot of Chief former Chiefs of the mission in this room that
39:4439 minutes, 44 secondsunderstand business and understand the importance uh and that's exactly why uh what we want to do is get a consistent uh message out that says Hey look you
39:5239 minutes, 52 secondsknow this is something that's very important uh you know Economic Security of course is part of our national security back home and it's it's key for
39:5939 minutes, 59 secondsus to uh uh to underscore the importance of U.S of U.S business I you know in in conversations I've had with other departments including defense uh for
40:0740 minutes, 7 secondsexample they recognize also the importance of that they look at the Ian dime and they say you know what can we do to do more so folks are are recognizing the importance of getting
40:1540 minutes, 15 secondstogether as a whole government uh to uh to to Really uh strategically uh compete uh help our companies compete and use
40:2240 minutes, 22 secondsour companies to uh to help us uh spread the message of of the importance of uh of what the United States offers uh the
40:2940 minutes, 29 secondsworld uh you know today and and uh yeah so I think the the economic uh economic diplomacy Action Group and and the
40:3840 minutes, 38 secondsmessaging that will come out in the weeks ahead on that will do more to to craft uh uh the importance to our chief submission uh of of their work and of
40:4540 minutes, 45 secondstheir support for for business um for me uh you know as a as a as a field practitioner myself uh you know I
40:5240 minutes, 52 secondsI always try to make sure not only that the ambassadors are not only seeing uh the big companies when they come in with issues but also the small guys that are coming in and trying to do things
41:0141 minutes, 1 secondbecause those guys are are often leading uh you know groundbreaking uh opportunity for for our our other companies that are like them uh in these
41:0941 minutes, 9 secondsmarkets so it's it's a to do more in both spaces would be absolutely great and I think you'll see more messaging that way
41:1541 minutes, 15 secondsthank you very much thank you thanks we'll now move on to the first panel
Chapter 7: Panel introduction
41:4441 minutes, 44 secondsokay
41:5541 minutes, 55 secondsall right there we go we're almost color coordinated um not quite some of us got the memo yeah well good
42:0442 minutes, 4 secondsmorning everyone my name is Matthew Goodman I'm senior vice president here at csis and I direct our economics program and have a great interest in
42:1342 minutes, 13 secondsthis subject of of commercial diplomacy which is a really important tool of U.S economic statecraft which we focus on in
42:2042 minutes, 20 secondsour program so I'm delighted to to be here with a terrific panel that I'm going to introduce in a second to frame
42:2742 minutes, 27 secondsthe problem the next panel has to solve the problem we just have to frame the problem so we've got the easy part here
42:3542 minutes, 35 secondsum but we're going to talk for about a little over an hour and uh well as a
42:4242 minutes, 42 secondspanel we'll talk for about 45 minutes of that and then we're going to invite questions from the audience there are microphones here in the room or if you
42:5042 minutes, 50 secondsonline push the button on your screen you should be able to ask an online question and I think I can just barely read the screen from here so I'll be
42:5742 minutes, 57 secondsable to to uh to read out the questions to our panelists but um there are two kinds of panels at csis
43:0543 minutes, 5 secondsthey're kind of analog panels and they're now chat GPT panels where you just put in a question and you get a perfectly honed five paragraph answer
43:1343 minutes, 13 secondsand that's this panel but there's nothing artificial about the intelligence up here there's a lot of
43:2143 minutes, 21 secondsinsight and experience here I've worked with or for most of these people and I can you'll see in a second that they're
43:2843 minutes, 28 secondsthey're the best in the business and so I'm just going to introduce them going down the line from here Michelle O'Neill is currently vice president for Global
43:3643 minutes, 36 secondsgovernment Affairs at Corning Incorporated she's worked at other companies here in town but but most importantly from this point of view
43:4543 minutes, 45 secondstoday and my own personal interaction with her goes way back she was at the Department of Commerce for a a long career and ultimately was Deputy under
43:5343 minutes, 53 secondssecretary for international trade at Commerce and I think is a well-known figure here in a csis audience so welcome Michelle next to her is Craig
44:0244 minutes, 2 secondsAllen also well known I think think to many of you he is President of the U.S China Business Council prior to that he had a long distinguished career at the
44:1044 minutes, 10 secondsCommerce department and then at the end as ambassador to Brunei darasalam so he's also been sort of well of course in
44:1944 minutes, 19 secondsembassies he's been in the state world but he's uh he's got he sort of bridges Both Worlds and a long time Commerce Department
44:2744 minutes, 27 secondsofficial and we work together in Tokyo Longo he likes to think FEMA's itself as a China person but I still think of him as a Japan guy from way back in the day
44:3544 minutes, 35 secondsso that's great and then Kathy Novelli again well known I think to this group senior advisor at Shearwater Global she's also president of listening for
44:4544 minutes, 45 secondsAmerica a non-partisan non-profit organization dedicated to forging a new vision of U.S International Trade engagement so that's very interesting
44:5244 minutes, 52 secondsand be interested if you can introduce that into this conversation and what you're what you're trying to do there because it sounds like it overlaps but
45:0045 minutesKathy as I think everyone knows was under Secretary of State 8 for economic growth energy and the environment in the Obama Administration and again welcome
45:0945 minutes, 9 secondsback Kathy and last but not least is Tony Wayne Ambassador Anthony Wayne is public policy fellow at the Woodrow
45:1745 minutes, 17 secondsWilson International Center for Scholars and co-chair of its Mexico Institute Advisory board he has a number of other Think Tank and academic affiliations he
45:2645 minutes, 26 secondsalso has a 40-year career in the in diplomacy at the state department he was Ambassador to Argentina ambassador to
45:3445 minutes, 34 secondsMexico and I worked with him when he was a long time assistant Secretary of State for Economic and Business Affairs so
45:4145 minutes, 41 secondsdelighted to have Tony with us as well okay now I'm going to mix things up and I'm going to just sort of to make it
45:5045 minutes, 50 secondsinteresting I'm actually going to start with you Kathy although I'm largely going to ask the same question of everyone which is to explain because I in the last in the in the two opening
45:5845 minutes, 58 secondsKeynotes we heard a lot of different words used around this term commercial diplomacy and I'm still not 100 sure that our audience or even I know exactly
46:0746 minutes, 7 secondswhat commercial diplomacy is because we heard things about advocacy about making deals about Market access can can you
46:1546 minutes, 15 secondshelp to Define what it is and why it's important why are we up here talking about it um well I think it is all those things I
46:2246 minutes, 22 secondsI mean I think that um and and if I could also say I think it intersects so much with our foreign policy
46:3046 minutes, 30 secondsand I think uh Tony is one of the folks who understands that and then did understand that I think there's a lot of um
46:3846 minutes, 38 secondsforeign Junior Foreign Service officers maybe who don't understand that and think their job is to only talk about
46:4546 minutes, 45 secondsyou know these big policy things but actually I think commercial diplomacy is
46:5246 minutes, 52 secondsabout what makes Commerce go both in our country and in another country and that involves advocacy for
47:0147 minutes, 1 secondour own companies because that's who we represent we represent our citizens our constituents but I think it also involves
47:1047 minutes, 10 secondsum as as the uh as was just said it also involves making hospitable environments so our companies can actually flourish
47:1947 minutes, 19 secondsin other uh countries including export and so with all this emphasis on manufacturing
47:2647 minutes, 26 secondshere you want to be able to export also what you're making here and it's not
47:3347 minutes, 33 secondsjust about investment to manufacture someplace else and so if there's not a hospitable environment there then it
47:4147 minutes, 41 secondsmakes it really really hard so I think it's all those things I think it's advocacy I think it's policy I think it's foreign policy and its Economic
47:4947 minutes, 49 secondsPolicy great um Tony do you want to sort of give a state perspective as well on on this question what is it and why does it matter
47:5847 minutes, 58 secondswell to build for on what Kathy has been talking about I start with a simple analogy when you play
48:0548 minutes, 5 secondsmany sports you have an offense and you have a defense and you have to have both in commercial diplomacy and economic
48:1248 minutes, 12 secondsdiplomacy is really the the offense it is to create that space for your companies to score to to create jobs to
48:2148 minutes, 21 secondsbuild wealth at home and the defense is where the last two administrations have
48:2848 minutes, 28 secondslargely focused their effort this is not a new challenge however we perceived
48:3548 minutes, 35 secondsearly in the American Academy of diplomacy in Ron Newman referred to the study they did back in two studies in 2016 2017 pointing out that most other
48:4548 minutes, 45 secondscountries in the world including our friends were out competing Us in the offense
48:5248 minutes, 52 secondsand I think that has become more serious with the rise of China around the world very competitive offense in many
49:0149 minutes, 1 secondcountries around the world and the United States over focusing on the defensive part of trying to just protect
49:0949 minutes, 9 secondsthe market and build up at home you have to do both and so the the commercial diplomacy economic diplomacy is trying
49:1749 minutes, 17 secondsto urge U.S agencies to work together at home and you and in the embassies
49:2449 minutes, 24 secondsoverseas to create that space for the economic wins that help bring
49:3249 minutes, 32 secondsjobs back home now they also create jobs in other countries at times and they do good the same way that as you know many
49:4149 minutes, 41 secondslarge International companies invest in the United States and create economic wealth but this is all part of that
49:4849 minutes, 48 secondsinteraction between governments and the private sector that it that can really multiply the benefits going forward
49:5749 minutes, 57 secondsso I think that's what we're talking about here we're talking about a balanced overall economic policy and
50:0450 minutes, 4 secondswhat can be gained by having good commercial diplomacy good economic diplomacy okay well it's a little
50:1250 minutes, 12 secondssimplistic but we sort of got a state perspective over there and let's get a more sort of Commerce perspective on the same question Craig um what is it why does it matter uh so I
50:2150 minutes, 21 secondsagree with everything that has uh just been said but uh commercial diplomacy from a Department of Commerce perspective largely it's a microeconomic
50:2950 minutes, 29 secondsEnterprise it's facilitating uh transactions and facilitating services for individual companies so when we talk
50:3750 minutes, 37 secondsabout commercial diplomacy from a Department of Commerce perspective there is a specific company with a specific need in a specific market and we support
50:4750 minutes, 47 secondsthem to obtain the appropriate services that they need now in many cases uh and
50:5550 minutes, 55 secondsindeed I would argue in most cases uh those transactional type of facilitation
51:0351 minutes, 3 secondsServices would be given to small and medium-sized Enterprises and from a Department of Commerce perspective
51:1151 minutes, 11 secondsindeed uh it's very uh one gets brownie points uh if one helps a new to Market export company if there's a company
51:2051 minutes, 20 secondsthat's manufacturing something but is never exported before getting them into their first Market is is a big deal uh
51:2851 minutes, 28 secondsif there's a company that's exporting to Canada or Mexico getting them into their third Market be it in Europe or Asia is
51:3651 minutes, 36 secondsa big deal so uh Dale mentioned some 25 uh different services that the Department of Commerce has to facilitate
51:4551 minutes, 45 secondsuh individual companies as CEOs and Export managers and marketing managers
51:5251 minutes, 52 secondswithin those companies to actually make uh those deals and I I won't kind of
51:5851 minutes, 58 secondscatalog them here but I would note uh that at the macroeconomic level there's
52:0652 minutes, 6 secondsa lot of trade missions and helping American companies and big trade shows uh overseas uh finding uh an American
52:1552 minutes, 15 secondscompany the best agent or or distributor uh appropriate uh to their needs in in
52:2252 minutes, 22 secondsWarsaw or Lima Peru uh where wherever it may be would be uh an important Service
52:2952 minutes, 29 secondsuh that uh the Department of Commerce would uh would provide um and I would uh note also at least by
52:3852 minutes, 38 secondsmy definition uh commercial diplomacy would include encouraging foreign direct investment in the United States to the
52:4752 minutes, 47 secondsextent that it it creates uh jobs uh in the United States so the ultimate final
52:5452 minutes, 54 secondskind of currency that we're talking about here is American jobs uh how many jobs are created through exports uh or
53:0453 minutes, 4 secondsthrough uh inbound investment and to the extent that we have facilitated uh job creation or job support then we have
53:1253 minutes, 12 secondsbeen successful to the extent that we are not facilitating job creation uh uh then uh we're not engaged in appropriate
53:2053 minutes, 20 secondscommercial diplomacy thank you okay thank you Craig and there's a lot more that I want to follow up with you on but Michelle so you're the only person on
53:2853 minutes, 28 secondsstage currently working for a single company um so but you also have this experience at the Commerce Department working on these issues so again how would you
53:3753 minutes, 37 secondsexplain what commercial diplomacy is and why it matters it's a great ad it's a great question and the benefit I have in going after
53:4653 minutes, 46 secondsall these folks is everything that's been said is I I completely agree with I think that what I haven't heard enough about and I
53:5553 minutes, 55 secondswould let me slightly detour from the question that I'd rather answer is um is how do you we all agree on the
54:0454 minutes, 4 secondsimportance we agree on the programs we agree I love the offensive defense characterization Craig you and I have
54:1254 minutes, 12 secondsbeen on the front lines doing these programs during our days at the Commerce Department worked closely with State all of the mechanisms exist the programs
Chapter 8: Panel discussion
54:2054 minutes, 20 secondsexist what I sense in the room is a frustration for how do you elevate that how do you make sure that it receives within the bureaucracy the
54:2754 minutes, 27 secondsprioritization that it needs and within the business community and other stakeholders so what I haven't heard a lot about is I am clear on what Commerce
54:3554 minutes, 35 secondsdoes I'm clear on what state does you know where are the other constituencies I don't know that commercial diplomacy
54:4254 minutes, 42 secondsis a topic that's regularly discussed in the c-suite and corporate boards I'm I don't hear enough of it from Capitol
54:5054 minutes, 50 secondsHill what about the governors what about those states that directly benefit all of the mechanisms and tools exist but
54:5754 minutes, 57 secondshow do we all work together to create that constituency so that when a new Administration comes in it's a priority
55:0555 minutes, 5 secondsit's a given it's something that's adequately resource and there's always going to be a need for more resources how many times have we been you know on
55:1355 minutes, 13 secondsthe front lines of we need more money we need more officers we need more locally engaged staff that question will persist
55:2055 minutes, 20 secondsthe question then is how do we lift this up how do we prioritize this topic among some of the other key stakeholders it can't just be about the Commerce
55:2955 minutes, 29 secondsdepartment and the state department working better together right in fact good because I was actually going to ask next sort of you know what is working
55:3655 minutes, 36 secondswhat isn't working in this in this space and so you've already started to answer that question but um Kathy go ahead you asked me to weave in what I found when I
55:4555 minutes, 45 secondswas doing listening sessions and one of the things I found actually that totally speaks to what Michelle saying is is
55:5255 minutes, 52 secondsthat Mayors are off doing their own commercial diplomacy and they have at
56:0056 minutesleast several told me they didn't feel like they were getting very good support from you know the state department folks
56:0856 minutes, 8 secondsin country et cetera so they just kind of took it upon themselves to go off and help of their companies you know win
56:1756 minutes, 17 secondscontracts abroad and as Craig was talking about bring people to their cities and I was kind of I was really
56:2556 minutes, 25 secondssurprised and the other thing I found is that a lot of companies have no idea what services they can Avail themselves
56:3356 minutes, 33 secondsof and so I think and that's true even of big companies not just I mean maybe the big defense guys or the big
56:4156 minutes, 41 secondsconstruction folks they know about it but I think a lot of other people just don't know I I love this focus on local and state we had a series which I'm
56:5056 minutes, 50 secondsstill hoping to revive and do another season of but we called economy disrupted a sort of webcast podcast
56:5756 minutes, 57 secondswhere um and we interviewed Mayors and governors and with we talked about a dozen of them in our last season the
57:0457 minutes, 4 secondsmayor of Oklahoma City of Phoenix the governor of New Hampshire Arkansas Washington State Oregon um and uh and I think without exception
57:1357 minutes, 13 secondsthey all talked about these issues and how they were out trying to promote you know trade and going on delegations or to promote inbound investment in their
57:2057 minutes, 20 secondscity or state and it's obviously a major priority for um you know for um for these these folks
57:2757 minutes, 27 secondsat the sub Federal level so that doesn't seem to be as much a part of the conversation or at least in the public conversation here in Washington as it as
57:3657 minutes, 36 secondsit might be Tony did you want to absolutely one of the parts of this new legislation actually calls for the establishment of a public-private
57:4457 minutes, 44 secondscommission that would include not just businesses but some other Representatives like local governments because it recognized I said that's
57:5157 minutes, 51 secondssomething we haven't done well as as a government as ambassador to Mexico I used to get States coming all the time and cities coming all the time because
57:5957 minutes, 59 secondsMexico is right next door so they sort of understood that and it wasn't as challenging as going to some of those far away markets so there's a great
58:0758 minutes, 7 secondsawareness out there and we're just not organized well to do that in the U.S
58:1458 minutes, 14 secondsgovernment so one of the things I know this is sort of boring bureaucratic things but as was mentioned this new legislation is sort of pressing the US
58:2458 minutes, 24 secondsgovernment to work more like a team and it's pressing the US government to work more with the broader private sector each of the agencies have sort of the
58:3358 minutes, 33 secondsbig companies you know when one group that comes to talk to them but what you need is this Outreach Commerce has an Outreach they're largely focused on smes
58:4258 minutes, 42 secondsbut and state just established a state local government office because it recognized that they weren't doing this
58:4958 minutes, 49 secondsOutreach but that's part of what needs to be developed and the goal is really to have a series of well-working mechanisms that can continue on because
58:5858 minutes, 58 secondstoo often what you've seen is between administrations you've sort of let the things that worked well Fall by the wayside and then the new Administration
59:0659 minutes, 6 secondslearns again things so by the last two years they start doing the things that it would have been nice if they'd done from the start
59:1559 minutes, 15 secondsCraig um when you were doing this um did you connect with um at the you know local government level
59:2359 minutes, 23 secondsum with uh with folks that were trying to promote International yeah um so so let's let's parse some of the numbers
59:3259 minutes, 32 secondsum Dale had mentioned that there are about 250 uh foreign commercial service officers in about a hundred cities in in
59:4059 minutes, 40 secondsthe United States so that's less than uh one officer per million people so you
59:4659 minutes, 46 secondslook at an uh a large uh Urban uh area uh Chicago you would have three or four
59:5359 minutes, 53 secondsuh officers and I I think that these are not well-resourced offices uh they're
1:00:001 hournot particularly uh um uh well connected with the local government
1:00:081 hour, 8 secondsI do think the resources are an issue here and if resources were expanded and
1:00:141 hour, 14 secondsand those arrangements formalized that that could really help across my career
1:00:211 hour, 21 secondsJapan South Africa uh uh China we welcomed Governors all the time uh
1:00:281 hour, 28 secondsMayors all the time and we would consider the companies that would come with the mayor and with the governor uh to be the same as a commercial service
1:00:371 hour, 37 secondsor organized uh group um uh we only wanted to get them planted
1:00:441 hour, 44 secondsin the market with an appropriate agent or distributor to begin a channel to open a Channel of exports uh to that
1:00:541 hour, 54 secondsparticular Market but I the resources are important Dale was a little bit uh shy to talk about this uh I the
1:01:021 hour, 1 minute, 2 secondsresources are are necessary uh if we are going uh to uh have an export promotion
1:01:101 hour, 1 minute, 10 secondsand a commercial diplomacy program that we really uh need uh and uh bare minimum
1:01:181 hour, 1 minute, 18 secondsin my view would be on top of about a 400 million dollar uh budget would be
1:01:251 hour, 1 minute, 25 secondsexpanding that by 25 percent would be a good start adding uh a hundred uh new people domestically in the United States
1:01:341 hour, 1 minute, 34 seconds100 new foreign staff overseas to actually make the one-to-one
1:01:421 hour, 1 minute, 42 secondsconnection to you to find your agent or distributor and perhaps another 25 officers that would be in my view a a
1:01:501 hour, 1 minute, 50 secondsgood start uh were quite a ways from that but I think that that's necessary to just
1:01:581 hour, 1 minute, 58 secondscatch up with uh the competition uh president macron uh took 50 French
1:02:051 hour, 2 minutes, 5 secondsbusinesses to China they sold an awful lot of equipment I I struggled to see President Biden taking businesses with
1:02:141 hour, 2 minutes, 14 secondshim on his uh foreign trips I wish he did if he's not then Secretary of Commerce or Secretary of State uh the
1:02:231 hour, 2 minutes, 23 secondsgovernors should and they should be applauded for doing so for the economic development of their prospective
1:02:311 hour, 2 minutes, 31 secondsconstituency I do want to come back to this question sort of what we're competing against what we're up against but before we get to that um Michelle again you're representing a
1:02:401 hour, 2 minutes, 40 secondscompany that's a household name literally I have Corning products still in my house that I inherited from my parents that you don't make it that you
1:02:481 hour, 2 minutes, 48 secondsdon't make anymore but um but um uh but but you know why does Corning I mean everybody knows Corning right so
1:02:561 hour, 2 minutes, 56 secondswhat what is what what's the benefit of having you know folks out in the field or or here advocating for you why would
1:03:051 hour, 3 minutes, 5 secondsyou need that or why would you don't have to talk about Corning but why would companies of your sort of size and and brand value
1:03:131 hour, 3 minutes, 13 secondsneed this these kinds of services well I suspect Kathy can speak to it too there's some things that an individual company can't do on its own and a lot of
1:03:221 hour, 3 minutes, 22 secondsit particularly for the larger companies tends to be in in some of those bigger policy questions I recall Kathy's sitting down with you and your uh
1:03:311 hour, 3 minutes, 31 secondsprivate when you were with apple and the Secretary of Commerce and talking about the importances of intellectual property rights protection I mean we have we haven't talked about that today but it's
1:03:391 hour, 3 minutes, 39 secondscritical so I think having that kind of advocacy is is really key the and then there's sometimes just to the the more
1:03:461 hour, 3 minutes, 46 secondstactical issues that Craig pointed out you know who are the key players in the market where are where is their demand for our products and services you know
1:03:551 hour, 3 minutes, 55 secondsas a check we can't be everywhere either and in some countries where we don't have representation it is terrific to be
1:04:041 hour, 4 minutes, 4 secondsable to call on the services of the commercial on the commercial service or the state econ team standards questions you know some of those things that are
1:04:111 hour, 4 minutes, 11 secondsbig intractable issues that only government to government dialogue can advance in and move forward on but then there there also it's it is great in
1:04:201 hour, 4 minutes, 20 secondscertain markets to be able to go over to the Embassy and host an event with our customers nothing uh you know has more
1:04:271 hour, 4 minutes, 27 secondssort of cachet or profile than an event with the U.S embassy in certain markets so all those kinds of things
1:04:341 hour, 4 minutes, 34 secondsare important and probably I'm arguing against interest we don't charge the companies enough for those services but
1:04:421 hour, 4 minutes, 42 secondsthat's another question for another time but I also think that um just that
1:04:491 hour, 4 minutes, 49 secondscompanies being in these other markets particularly in the developing markets can have an incredible impact on their
1:04:581 hour, 4 minutes, 58 secondsown so you know as a policy person from the government arguing for all these changes sometimes companies can
1:05:061 hour, 5 minutes, 6 secondsdemonstrate why those changes actually will help enhance not just their own
1:05:131 hour, 5 minutes, 13 secondswell-being in that country but the you know the local companies well-being too and I think that can be a catalyst for
1:05:221 hour, 5 minutes, 22 secondschange as well um and you know it trains people who are uh to be managers to you know Etc so I
1:05:311 hour, 5 minutes, 31 secondsthink that it is truly I saw a question pop up why is that a win-win it is absolutely win-win I think it's a win-win for us
1:05:401 hour, 5 minutes, 40 secondsum and I think it's not just offense I also think it's defense in the sense that other countries are like pushing
1:05:501 hour, 5 minutes, 50 secondsreally hard for their own companies to be there and sometimes some of those other companies practices may not be
1:05:581 hour, 5 minutes, 58 secondswhat we think are the greatest practices so what's then the you know what's being
1:06:061 hour, 6 minutes, 6 secondsshown by U.S companies I think is largely going to be what we think are good practices and that may not be the
1:06:141 hour, 6 minutes, 14 secondscase for others and and I again want to come back to sort of others and what we're up against but but first just Tony
1:06:211 hour, 6 minutes, 21 secondsis an ambassador again in the field a couple of times uh you know can you endorse this point that that actually
1:06:281 hour, 6 minutes, 28 secondsthe companies being there on the ground and delivering good products and services but also capacity and rule of law and other things are supporting our
1:06:361 hour, 6 minutes, 36 secondsbroader foreign policy interests I don't mean to ask a leading question but do they do that do they do well I I served
1:06:441 hour, 6 minutes, 44 secondsonce in a country with the highest level of anti-americanism in the Americas and so one of the greatest tools for America
1:06:521 hour, 6 minutes, 52 secondswas the corporate responsibility programs of U.S companies in that Society with the care they took for
1:07:011 hour, 7 minutes, 1 secondtheir workers with the care they showed for the communities where they were based and we did all we could to
1:07:081 hour, 7 minutes, 8 secondshighlight those because it countered the stereotypic views of sort of rapacious capitalists coming in here to harm our
1:07:171 hour, 7 minutes, 17 secondscountry that wasn't the case at all many many great corporate citizens in this country that I worked in and and it does
1:07:261 hour, 7 minutes, 26 secondsmake a big difference and it it helps it not of course companies differ but the best companies really are living the
1:07:361 hour, 7 minutes, 36 secondsvalues that we share as America and helping spread those and just one other thing I'll just give a little antidote about what was said about
1:07:451 hour, 7 minutes, 45 secondsstate officers in some places where the state officers are the only ones there they do they work very closely with Commerce back in Washington they do both
1:07:541 hour, 7 minutes, 54 secondsthe tasks that econ and commerce officers do at other places in those places where there is a good Commerce
1:08:021 hour, 8 minutes, 2 secondspartner there at the embassy we do a lot of what was being talked about of helping to fix policy and I'm just going to give one example the first time I
1:08:111 hour, 8 minutes, 11 secondsrealized how important economics are and how important an embassy can be I was sitting in Brussels at the meeting
1:08:181 hour, 8 minutes, 18 secondsuh going at the embassy to the European Union the mission to the European Union and we sat in a meeting with a U.S tech
1:08:271 hour, 8 minutes, 27 secondscompany that is is now not the largest but was a very large one there the guys were explaining to us how this one
1:08:351 hour, 8 minutes, 35 secondsregulation by the European commission would make 250 million dollars difference this was way back in 1990 so
1:08:421 hour, 8 minutes, 42 secondsthat was a lot of money in annual in in sort of the annual opportunities if we they could get to talk to them and have
1:08:491 hour, 8 minutes, 49 secondsan under uh this discussion of the real substance of the issue and so we helped arrange them to have a conversation they
1:08:571 hour, 8 minutes, 57 secondsdid fix the issue and so I learned that this is something that Norms rules regulations do make a big difference and
1:09:051 hour, 9 minutes, 5 secondsthat was just consistently reinforced around the world that if you could sometimes go in and and ex and and
1:09:131 hour, 9 minutes, 13 secondsexplain why this was not the best standard the best Norm the best regulation you could open a lot of opportunities and there were
1:09:221 hour, 9 minutes, 22 secondsopportunities for American companies but there were also opportunities for their own local companies at other times to to grow more so there's a lot you can do in
1:09:301 hour, 9 minutes, 30 secondsall the different aspects of interacting with a host government great and I was going to say I should have encouraged earlier stories are good
1:09:381 hour, 9 minutes, 38 secondswe would like to hear stories from your experience in the in the field in particular but um and let me also remind the online audience that your questions
1:09:471 hour, 9 minutes, 47 secondsare welcome so please start um submitting those and we'll get to those in in a few minutes um uh Craig
1:09:551 hour, 9 minutes, 55 secondsum I mean there's so much to talk about here but I a couple of people have referred to others who are making offerings like this so let's let's explore that a little bit you work on
1:10:041 hour, 10 minutes, 4 secondsChina now there's no panel at CSS that's complete without a discussion of China but but um I know you're more focused on the
1:10:111 hour, 10 minutes, 11 secondssort of bilateral flows but but from your experience in the field I mean what is trying to just trying to do this stuff
1:10:181 hour, 10 minutes, 18 secondsum and and is it effective and how do we sort of respond to that and then we'll talk about France again let me return to
1:10:281 hour, 10 minutes, 28 secondsthe previous discussion first I'm sometimes befuddled at the criticism
1:10:351 hour, 10 minutes, 35 secondsof American companies of behavior abroad uh in China American companies are
1:10:421 hour, 10 minutes, 42 secondsconsidered to be eight of the top ten employers in uh in the country and
1:10:491 hour, 10 minutes, 49 secondsAmerican companies are exemplars of uh American values we are absolutely not corrupt uh good labor practices good
1:10:581 hour, 10 minutes, 58 secondssafety practices uh a very good CSR practices uh gender equality the whole
1:11:051 hour, 11 minutes, 5 secondsthing uh modeling uh Behavior said uh uh need to be modeled uh in a developing
1:11:131 hour, 11 minutes, 13 secondsMarket the Chinese are very uh a very good uh at commercial
1:11:231 hour, 11 minutes, 23 secondsdiplomacy they have a lot of programs to bring
1:11:311 hour, 11 minutes, 31 secondstheir companies to trade shows abroad uh facilitated
1:11:381 hour, 11 minutes, 38 secondsby local government often time so there are local governments uh provincial governments will have large Pavilions
1:11:471 hour, 11 minutes, 47 secondsadd trade shows in Europe or the United States are are around uh the world they
1:11:531 hour, 11 minutes, 53 secondsalso are the the Chinese government is very active at bringing buyers to trade
1:12:011 hour, 12 minutes, 1 secondshows in China and so this is a a extremely Dynamic uh part of their
1:12:101 hour, 12 minutes, 10 secondscommercial diplomacy program I would note however that it's really the entrepreneurial Drive of particularly
1:12:181 hour, 12 minutes, 18 secondsthe private Chinese companies that's really uh leading to their export search and indeed
1:12:261 hour, 12 minutes, 26 secondstheir uh using a net export growth as a one of the two major engines uh behind
1:12:341 hour, 12 minutes, 34 secondstheir economic growth model and that has been very successful following in the footsteps of Japan and
1:12:411 hour, 12 minutes, 41 secondsKorea and Hong Kong and Taiwan before then um I think it's running out of steam um that that economic growth model
1:12:501 hour, 12 minutes, 50 secondsum and uh so it will be interesting to watch uh their commercial diplomacy in the future
1:12:571 hour, 12 minutes, 57 secondsum at the recent event in Guangzhou the Chinese Premier announced that it was
1:13:041 hour, 13 minutes, 4 secondsthe year of investment a foreign direct investment in China so they're doubling down on inbound investment promotion and
1:13:131 hour, 13 minutes, 13 secondsuh we'll see uh how successful that is um so great Michelle do you have sort of um perspective on this question of what
1:13:221 hour, 13 minutes, 22 secondswho else is doing this and not just China and maybe not just France although France often comes up has already come up today um as a as a
1:13:311 hour, 13 minutes, 31 secondsum you know a a place that does at least tries to do very focused you know commercial diplomacy and whether
1:13:391 hour, 13 minutes, 39 secondsit's successful or not is another question but have you seen that and where do you think uh the the competition is who's out there doing
1:13:471 hour, 13 minutes, 47 secondsthis better than us I guess a I'm feeling contrarian today Matt
1:13:541 hour, 13 minutes, 54 secondsum I I wonder are we really doing it badly I mean I I'm just I question the
1:14:031 hour, 14 minutes, 3 secondspremise right so I hear that we need more of our high level officials talking about this more we need more resources
1:14:111 hour, 14 minutes, 11 secondswith all due respect on the resource side this has been a perennial question I used to in my old job have to go up every year and defend you know whatever
1:14:191 hour, 14 minutes, 19 secondsbudget increase we were asking for you know and it was it was like any negotiation you start with one number and then you work sort of towards it and
1:14:271 hour, 14 minutes, 27 secondsthen you know there's a cut here or a plus up there but Craig do we really think that Commerce
1:14:351 hour, 14 minutes, 35 secondswill get a hundred more officers um in the Dem I mean you can ask for it no problem but so I guess I'm trying to
1:14:431 hour, 14 minutes, 43 secondsunderstand like is it really just that we need the president leading a trade Mission or we need the Secretary of Commerce leading a trade Mission I mean
1:14:511 hour, 14 minutes, 51 secondswe all know what effort and work goes into that I'm just wondering you know yes more resources more more visibility
1:14:591 hour, 14 minutes, 59 secondsbut I'm just not I'm not sure I'm trying to get my arms around what the problem is okay that's a big challenge you want to answer that
1:15:071 hour, 15 minutes, 7 secondsI think traditionally the United States has hung back and thought in many cases that the private sector can do it the
1:15:141 hour, 15 minutes, 14 secondsprivate sector can do all this and I think that's not true in a number of cases it's certainly not true for smaller companies but even in a number
1:15:231 hour, 15 minutes, 23 secondsof countries you need an entree to get in a lot of times and that's why the French and the British and others have been doing it now are they all
1:15:301 hour, 15 minutes, 30 secondssuccessful in doing it no they aren't all successful sometimes they'll still be U.S companies that will come out on top but it helps if you have
1:15:381 hour, 15 minutes, 38 secondsif you have sometimes a mission some but just a more organized system I mean I was 40 years in the government
1:15:461 hour, 15 minutes, 46 secondsand we were never well organized in supporting U.S businesses overseas except the biggest companies biggest
1:15:541 hour, 15 minutes, 54 secondscompanies got a lot of attention I won't say which one but there's one of them that we in the academic and Business Bureau support it all the time
1:16:011 hour, 16 minutes, 1 secondall around the world and they did really well but there's a whole field of there of others that can get that little extra
1:16:091 hour, 16 minutes, 9 secondsentry that extra help when they run into a blockade they could get an extra door unlocked to find a solution and that's
1:16:191 hour, 16 minutes, 19 secondswhat I think we can do better if we organize ourselves better and sure they're always going to be need for resources and and I've been pushing for
1:16:281 hour, 16 minutes, 28 secondsthe last five or six years to have 200 more economic officers around the world to compete with China because we saw in Africa in many other places China was
1:16:361 hour, 16 minutes, 36 secondsjust widely expanding and we just didn't have the staff there to do that we won't get them all but we have already gotten some and that's a big advance to go
1:16:451 hour, 16 minutes, 45 secondsforward but we just need to get better at coordinating among ourselves using the resources we have working with the private sector at various different
1:16:541 hour, 16 minutes, 54 secondslevels working with different levels of U.S of government state and local officials to get out there in this world it's a big giant World there are a lot
1:17:031 hour, 17 minutes, 3 secondsof opportunities and a lot of benefit if we do it better that's the basic pitch right well yeah no I think I think that's
1:17:111 hour, 17 minutes, 11 secondsright um I just would look back over time and say that that the mechanisms have existed and what you need to do is
1:17:191 hour, 17 minutes, 19 secondscreate and embed in the bureaucracy a commitment to it I think somebody said earlier we do one thing for the duration of administration then the new team
1:17:271 hour, 17 minutes, 27 secondscomes in yeah thank you a new team comes in and we reorder our priorities so the question then is if we
1:17:351 hour, 17 minutes, 35 secondsall agree and we think it's something that transcends politics and administrations how do you build the bureaucratic structure around that so
1:17:431 hour, 17 minutes, 43 secondsthat you know when Dale is briefing the assistant secretary or the secretary it's at the top of the list when
1:17:511 hour, 17 minutes, 51 secondscompanies come in to ask for support from the Commerce department they say things like commercial diplomacy commercial advocacy when the president's
1:18:001 hour, 18 minutesexport Council which has just been reconstituted that they say the words commercial diplomacy you know how do you build out
1:18:071 hour, 18 minutes, 7 secondsthat bureaucratic structure so that it is a given that's why the Congress passed this law that we're talking about which in fact lays out a number of the
1:18:161 hour, 18 minutes, 16 secondsthings that's going to remain law when the Biden Administration changes right and and I think all of these things are
1:18:231 hour, 18 minutes, 23 secondsadditive and they build on a foundation that exists I I just think we have to be careful to not either create a new
1:18:301 hour, 18 minutes, 30 secondsinteragency group or a new pass another law you know embed what's what exists
1:18:371 hour, 18 minutes, 37 secondsI think I think you're right about that and at least you know one of the things I again that I saw at state was that
1:18:451 hour, 18 minutes, 45 secondsfolks especially more Junior folks didn't necessarily see why that mattered right
1:18:541 hour, 18 minutes, 54 secondsand that's a problem state has to rectify in terms of how it rates people and things like that
1:19:021 hour, 19 minutes, 2 secondsum to me um and and I would also say I think um when you were asking Michelle well you
1:19:111 hour, 19 minutes, 11 secondsknow does it matter I think especially when there's head-to-head competition with other
1:19:181 hour, 19 minutes, 18 secondscompanies trying to do something you know it's not every small business or whatever but especially in places where
1:19:251 hour, 19 minutes, 25 secondsthere's head-to-head competition if the U.S isn't in there at a very senior level advocating then I think the
1:19:321 hour, 19 minutes, 32 secondscountry thinks that we don't care really and so all of that power that we could bring to bear to say this is an issue
1:19:421 hour, 19 minutes, 42 secondsit's a political issue it's not just an economic issue isn't there and other countries are bringing that to bear and
1:19:511 hour, 19 minutes, 51 secondsif I could say one other thing that I think is is a good advancement you know when I was at State one of the big
1:19:581 hour, 19 minutes, 58 secondscomplaints we got for some of these larger deals was that other countries had way better financing
1:20:061 hour, 20 minutes, 6 secondspackages than we did and we were so disjointed in what we could do and I think that has started to turn around
1:20:131 hour, 20 minutes, 13 secondssome with you know reorganization now so that opic OPEC pick was reorganized
1:20:221 hour, 20 minutes, 22 secondsand things were drawn in and I think we do have to look at that because you know it's hard to compete if the finances on
1:20:301 hour, 20 minutes, 30 secondsthe table are just not as good even if you have a great company so I think we have to look at this on multiple layers
1:20:381 hour, 20 minutes, 38 secondsyou know it's not just knocking on doors it's also providing the right tools I'm glad you introduced Finance because I was going to ask about that but so if
1:20:471 hour, 20 minutes, 47 secondsother want to comment on that Dimension I'd be interested in that and by the way when you said opic the old um overseas private Investment
1:20:551 hour, 20 minutes, 55 secondscorporation which is now merged into this new U.S International Development Finance Corporation known as DFC right and and they've got bigger a bigger
1:21:031 hour, 21 minutes, 3 secondscheckbook and ability to do more interesting things out there with more tools than they had at least in my view
1:21:121 hour, 21 minutes, 12 secondsthe uh this should be prioritized because there are many positive externalities uh at the local
1:21:211 hour, 21 minutes, 21 secondslevel at the firm level uh at the the state level to exporting um uh when there are exports there are
1:21:291 hour, 21 minutes, 29 secondsadditional jobs there's a lot of uh creativity engaged with that and the more you export the more Dynamic the
1:21:371 hour, 21 minutes, 37 secondslocality is so if we accept the premise that there are positive externalities to exporting then I think that we should uh
1:21:451 hour, 21 minutes, 45 secondscontemplate the proposition uh that's supporting that has a net public good
1:21:531 hour, 21 minutes, 53 secondsand I would be comfortable in in arguing that and that there has been a market failure a lot of uh small medium-sized
1:22:031 hour, 22 minutes, 3 secondsmanufacturers around the country would find it very difficult to begin exporting without support and those
1:22:101 hour, 22 minutes, 10 secondspeople will benefit their our communities if they receive effective support to find an agent or a
1:22:171 hour, 22 minutes, 17 secondsdistributor or a warehouser or an importer in Canada or Mexico or ideally in 5 10 15 or 30 or 70 countries around
1:22:271 hour, 22 minutes, 27 secondsthe world and uh that in my view uh creates a positive externalities that
1:22:351 hour, 22 minutes, 35 secondsare the proper purview of government interest and taxpayer support
1:22:421 hour, 22 minutes, 42 secondsum any other comments on the financial dimensions of this because I do think that's a critical piece that just only
1:22:491 hour, 22 minutes, 49 secondsyeah the second what Kathy said I remember a number of cases in the first 15 years or so of this Century where
1:22:581 hour, 22 minutes, 58 secondsother competitors were just coming in with better packages for financing and if you're a local government and a you
1:23:061 hour, 23 minutes, 6 secondsknow looking at that you're going to look at how much it's going to cost you and that's why we started trying to innovate
1:23:141 hour, 23 minutes, 14 secondsto come up with better Financial packages it did make a difference in a number of these bigger cases where we
1:23:201 hour, 23 minutes, 20 secondsjust lost because it was more expensive to buy American even if the quality was better well I was going to get to that
1:23:281 hour, 23 minutes, 28 secondsissue as well I mean is it just the financial package or is it you know the kind of the overall American package is kind of more expensive because it's
1:23:351 hour, 23 minutes, 35 secondsbetter quality it is you know often comes with more due diligence more work and environmental impact of a
1:23:431 hour, 23 minutes, 43 secondsparticularly Project based offerings and you know how do we are we not going to sacrifice that stuff so how do we
1:23:511 hour, 23 minutes, 51 secondscompensate for that cost disadvantage I think the difference is is the disparity like this or is it more like that you
1:24:011 hour, 24 minutes, 1 secondknow and so if it's more like that then you know a country can say okay this is way better yeah you get what you pay for so okay we're gonna pay more but if it's
1:24:101 hour, 24 minutes, 10 secondslike this I think it's a lot lot harder and you saw a lot of that on the Telecom side right you saw a ton of that when
1:24:191 hour, 24 minutes, 19 secondsyou know we were very concerned about Huawei but the disparity of what you could buy a Huawei system
1:24:281 hour, 24 minutes, 28 secondsfor and the U.S system was just gigantic and countries were like you know what this
1:24:351 hour, 24 minutes, 35 secondsworks I'm going to go ahead right right um yeah and um okay other thoughts on
1:24:421 hour, 24 minutes, 42 secondswell I think that the fact of the matter is other countries have their hand governments have their hand on the scale
1:24:481 hour, 24 minutes, 48 secondsin favor of their uh companies and if we're not going to have an offensive game then we're going to lose a lot of
1:24:561 hour, 24 minutes, 56 secondsdeals that we should otherwise win and that will have an impact on our longer term competitiveness right
1:25:031 hour, 25 minutes, 3 secondsum okay um if uh and again invite audience questions I see some starting to come up
1:25:111 hour, 25 minutes, 11 secondsbut but welcome more from the audience um if uh if we were going to
1:25:181 hour, 25 minutes, 18 secondshave to prioritize because resources are always constrained you know is there can I challenge people to say in public
1:25:261 hour, 25 minutes, 26 secondswhere you think those priorities ought to be I mean like regionally is there a part of the world that's more important than another part of the world or is
1:25:331 hour, 25 minutes, 33 secondsparticularly underserved is sectorally um there there are an area we should be more more focused than others Craig
1:25:411 hour, 25 minutes, 41 secondsyou're nodding well where's the gross uh follow the growth and the growth is in Asia between
1:25:491 hour, 25 minutes, 49 secondsIndia China and Southeast Asia that'll present some 60 percent of global growth that's where we need to put our our
1:25:571 hour, 25 minutes, 57 secondsassets that's where we need to make our investments that's where we need to be as competitive as possible now this is
1:26:041 hour, 26 minutes, 4 secondsvery difficult because uh unfortunately we are not members of the cptpp and or
1:26:121 hour, 26 minutes, 12 secondsthe regional cooperation and economic partnership our sep that is binding Asia together and so that is kind of outside
1:26:201 hour, 26 minutes, 20 secondsthe bounds of this discussion we're getting into more trade policy there but uh uh it it just underscores the fact uh
1:26:301 hour, 26 minutes, 30 secondsthat we need to support exporters into these markets who are integrating internally um without the United States uh being
1:26:391 hour, 26 minutes, 39 secondspart of behind the Tariff walls and that should worry all of us and I hope would
1:26:451 hour, 26 minutes, 45 secondsbe a Spur uh to more aggressive uh not uh commercial
1:26:521 hour, 26 minutes, 52 secondsdiplomacy but trade policy other other thoughts on priorities can we just add some of the countries
1:27:011 hour, 27 minutes, 1 secondthat we've got either existing Partnerships or trade agreements with and you know we talked a little bit about North America and you know usmca
1:27:091 hour, 27 minutes, 9 secondsyou know what more could be done within this region to build up U.S exports
1:27:161 hour, 27 minutes, 16 secondsMexico Canada commercial and economic ties I think would be time well spent that's a good site to you Tony I I agree
1:27:251 hour, 27 minutes, 25 secondsfully and we have another calculation now which is the need to have diverse and resilient Supply chains we were don't let's not forget all the
1:27:341 hour, 27 minutes, 34 secondsemergencies we went through last few years and so it's not just where the growth is it's what's going to be a sustainable
1:27:421 hour, 27 minutes, 42 secondssystem network of supply and production and I think we do need to look in the Americas there and I do think we can
1:27:491 hour, 27 minutes, 49 secondsbuild off the existing agreements that we have and in that I think the digital chapters are extremely important in what
1:27:561 hour, 27 minutes, 56 secondswe do which is something the Biden Administration has flagged is very important we have great advantages as
1:28:031 hour, 28 minutes, 3 secondsthe United States in the digital arena in services and we should be building on that strongly and trying to build a set
1:28:131 hour, 28 minutes, 13 secondsof norms and agreements and Arrangements that will help our companies and and our you know innovators but will help others
1:28:211 hour, 28 minutes, 21 secondscome into that and if you think about small medium Enterprises what greater facility is there than easy to use
1:28:281 hour, 28 minutes, 28 secondsDigital Services to help people connect around the region or around the world to build these new Supply chains in both
1:28:371 hour, 28 minutes, 37 secondsdirections and and so I think that does need to be continue to be a big focus and an area
1:28:451 hour, 28 minutes, 45 secondsof discussion because it's is this is one area we haven't really talked about yet but there are a number of issues
1:28:521 hour, 28 minutes, 52 secondsthat are international and domestic at exactly the same time and digital policy is one of those privacy which relates to that and the AI
1:29:011 hour, 29 minutes, 1 secondand all of that we have to treat these as both International and domestic at the same time and we need to build as
1:29:081 hour, 29 minutes, 8 secondsmuch as we can strong norms and standards and understandings domestically but also with our trading
1:29:161 hour, 29 minutes, 16 secondspartners as we go forward so I think that has to be a large priority for both trade policy and for commercial policy
1:29:241 hour, 29 minutes, 24 secondswell that's Music Matters we're doing a lot of work at csas on those issues and and agree that those are those are really critical to the to all of these
1:29:331 hour, 29 minutes, 33 secondsefforts and and other things as well um that that we all care about um does anybody else want to comment on prioritization
1:29:491 hour, 29 minutes, 49 secondsuh did a study with state that showed that a 10 increase in access to the
1:29:581 hour, 29 minutes, 58 secondsinternet resulted in a one percent increase in GDP in a developing country I mean that
1:30:071 hour, 30 minutes, 7 secondsis amazing right and so to me part of the priority is policy
1:30:131 hour, 30 minutes, 13 secondsit's it's it is privacy it's those things but it's also Telecom policy and
1:30:201 hour, 30 minutes, 20 secondsit's helping our telecom companies to operate outside our bounds and having
1:30:271 hour, 30 minutes, 27 secondsreally good um access kinds of questions auctions for spectrum satellite all
1:30:361 hour, 30 minutes, 36 secondsthose things that our companies are expert at doing and have opportunities to do and I think we in commercial
1:30:431 hour, 30 minutes, 43 secondsdiplomacy haven't really kind of put a push on that but to Tony's point I think it's it's though the policies he
1:30:521 hour, 30 minutes, 52 secondsmentioned but I think it's broader and that we really need to think about prioritizing that sector not just only a
1:31:011 hour, 31 minutes, 1 secondregion okay let's hope Michelle did you want to say anything about prioritization regionally or separately anything else no I would go back to just
1:31:101 hour, 31 minutes, 10 secondsthe the I keep not answering your questions man sorry um I've known him too long now I would just go back to the priority setting right so I'm gonna
1:31:181 hour, 31 minutes, 18 secondsDale's still here so I'm just picking on the commercial service because it's what I know well but there used to be an exercise that the service did every few years where you looked at all of those
1:31:261 hour, 31 minutes, 26 secondskey factors you know where which countries are growing which have you know rule of law you know hospitable business environments the ease of doing
1:31:351 hour, 31 minutes, 35 secondsbusiness we used to talk about that a fair bit and you looked at the resources that you were allocated and then you
1:31:421 hour, 31 minutes, 42 secondsdrew a line time and you funded everything above the line and you broke the bad news to everybody below the line
1:31:491 hour, 31 minutes, 49 secondsand oftentimes you know and having a conversation with the state department maybe that's where the partnership posts
1:31:561 hour, 31 minutes, 56 secondscome in but it's just a recognition that resources are finite and you can't do everything well and I I would say I I
1:32:051 hour, 32 minutes, 5 secondshad you know by anecdote I had a a I won't name the country or the administration but we did this exercise
1:32:121 hour, 32 minutes, 12 secondswhen I was at in the international trade Administration my job was to present it to OMB and get approval then to the
1:32:201 hour, 32 minutes, 20 secondsWhite House and I got a call and it was how could you cut your post in this
1:32:271 hour, 32 minutes, 27 secondscritical African country that's a critical partner for us and I said well with all due respect I have one locally
1:32:351 hour, 32 minutes, 35 secondsengaged staff there and there is no post there is no commercial service presence when you
1:32:421 hour, 32 minutes, 42 secondshave one locally engaged staff if it's that much of a priority tell me where I should move the resources you know I'm
1:32:491 hour, 32 minutes, 49 secondshappy to come over and show you the analysis both qualitative and quantitative and the answer came back it's a priority of the president's you
1:32:571 hour, 32 minutes, 57 secondscan't close that office so we kept it going and those of you at the state department know and Commercial service how much it costs to keep one person at
1:33:061 hour, 33 minutes, 6 secondsa post in country so I think I leave you with that to just say that those are the tough questions that happen within the bureaucracy and
1:33:141 hour, 33 minutes, 14 secondsbehind the scenes that I think have to continue to happen and the partnership that we talked about before is critical okay there's more I want to do up here
Chapter 9: Audience Q&A
1:33:221 hour, 33 minutes, 22 secondsbut I see there's a gentleman waiting patiently at the microphone and he's modeling for the others in the room if you would like to ask a question please
1:33:291 hour, 33 minutes, 29 secondsstand behind that gentleman and then you can I'll call on you after him but please identify yourself and then ask a question
1:33:361 hour, 33 minutes, 36 secondsthank you I'm Ludovic Arnold from the University of Oxford I have a question on the role of the Department of Justice
1:33:441 hour, 33 minutes, 44 secondsin shaping commercial diplomacy you brought friends a lot and in France in 2013 there was the acquisition by
1:33:521 hour, 33 minutes, 52 secondsGeneral Electric of Alston and that was when Alston which is the big nuclear company was investigated
1:34:001 hour, 34 minutesunder the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act by the US Department of Justice and this created a lot of pressure
1:34:071 hour, 34 minutes, 7 secondson the board of Alston to sell the company so the question would be first is the Department of are you collaborating with
1:34:161 hour, 34 minutes, 16 secondsthe Department of Justice to promote a Level Playing Field which would be a more defensive approach I guess and second is there still more action on a
1:34:251 hour, 34 minutes, 25 secondsmore offensive strategy um to promote the interest of U.S firms through the justice department so I know
1:34:321 hour, 34 minutes, 32 secondsit I know it's not a really diplomatic question but we like and diplomatic questions but there are a lot of diplomats up here so they can handle it but but uh I mean there's a specific
1:34:411 hour, 34 minutes, 41 secondsquestion or two in there but I'd also say more broadly I was going to ask about the foreign Practices Act and whether that ties our hands or is
1:34:491 hour, 34 minutes, 49 secondssomething that you know we live with and because it's important and it's the law how does it constrain our our presence
1:34:581 hour, 34 minutes, 58 secondsyou know commercially but Craig did you want to take on so I would say to you to your question the Department of Justice uh has Primacy over mergers and
1:35:061 hour, 35 minutes, 6 secondsAcquisitions in the United States and uh they coordinate oftentimes times with other mergers and Acquisitions
1:35:161 hour, 35 minutes, 16 secondsentities or Regulators around the world and they're incredibly independent uh
1:35:221 hour, 35 minutes, 22 secondswithin the the U.S system and uh their their operations and uh very uh very
1:35:301 hour, 35 minutes, 30 secondsconsistent uh in uh employing their their principles
1:35:371 hour, 35 minutes, 37 secondsum with their fellow Regulators around uh the world uh with regard to the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act um I would
1:35:451 hour, 35 minutes, 45 secondssay what a blessing it is uh that uh that uh we don't have to
1:35:531 hour, 35 minutes, 53 secondsum even entertain uh the thought of any Corrupt Practices that we could just say simply that we're Americans I'm sorry we
1:36:011 hour, 36 minutes, 1 secondcan't uh engage in Corrupt Practices and that's the biggest blessing that American companies have uh and uh those
1:36:091 hour, 36 minutes, 9 secondsuh kind of sustainable business deals and joint ventures and operations that we have around the world are there uh
1:36:181 hour, 36 minutes, 18 secondsnot for corrupt reasons but because they're economically viable and having worked in a number of
1:36:241 hour, 36 minutes, 24 secondslocations that are well known for corruption I find it just a complete blessing to have that law underneath us
1:36:331 hour, 36 minutes, 33 secondsTony you have a little bit of experience here okay just to add that that in fact the
1:36:401 hour, 36 minutes, 40 secondsforeign Praxis act what was put in place because the playing field was very unlevel because many governments around
1:36:491 hour, 36 minutes, 49 secondsthe world including our closest Partners completely allowed their companies to pay whatever they had to pay to get a contract and so we worked very hard to
1:36:581 hour, 36 minutes, 58 secondsbuild a consensus we got an oecd agreement in the 1990s that everybody in the oecd signed up to but not many or
1:37:071 hour, 37 minutes, 7 secondsmany did not want to follow until they realized what their economic diplomats had committed them to and then gradually
1:37:151 hour, 37 minutes, 15 secondsover a period of time we have expanded the consensus of sort of rules of the road in dealing with corruption it's
1:37:231 hour, 37 minutes, 23 secondsvery healthy for the recipient countries for the the selling countries for your partner
1:37:301 hour, 37 minutes, 30 secondsthe country and companies going forward to have an understanding that where you can't use corruption unless you want to
1:37:391 hour, 37 minutes, 39 secondstake the chance of being caught and paying a very big price either reputationally or possibly criminally in the United States and now a number of
1:37:471 hour, 37 minutes, 47 secondsother governments in Europe and elsewhere have similar laws that they put in place so this is very healthy now the other implicit thing here is the
1:37:551 hour, 37 minutes, 55 secondscepheus process and the investment process and now the export process which is going on which also is applying
1:38:031 hour, 38 minutes, 3 secondsdifferent kind of filters two commercial economic activities involving U.S
1:38:111 hour, 38 minutes, 11 secondscompanies and international companies and and that's a much more complicated process another area that I wanted to explore and we'll come back to if we
1:38:201 hour, 38 minutes, 20 secondshave time but unless anyone else wants to comment on that and I know you're waiting patiently there but so is the person online there's been a question up
1:38:271 hour, 38 minutes, 27 secondsthere from Anne moisen of the near east south Asia Center for strategic studies who asked win-win was referred to by the
1:38:351 hour, 38 minutes, 35 secondsspeakers please specify how Med countries which I assume is not Mediterranean but medium-sized countries and partners can use this to their
1:38:441 hour, 38 minutes, 44 secondsbenefits since they are since they need jobs too and their stability is the U.S national security issue so I guess that means if the the premise of the question
1:38:531 hour, 38 minutes, 53 secondsis that if we're just exporting stuff to these countries that's not somehow win-win for them and we need to do more
1:38:591 hour, 38 minutes, 59 secondsto support them if I understood the question does anybody want to challenge that premise or offer what we could do I
1:39:081 hour, 39 minutes, 8 secondsdon't agree with the premise personally but I'm not a panelist clearly it's a two-way street and right now we're importing a lot more than we are exporting so many countries around the
1:39:171 hour, 39 minutes, 17 secondsworld are benefiting from the U.S market and we've tried to keep our Market open with a set of basic general rules under
1:39:251 hour, 39 minutes, 25 secondsthe WTO and then if we have specific trade agreements we negotiate those agreements with either a group of individual countries
1:39:321 hour, 39 minutes, 32 secondsso I think the basic premise of our policy has consistently been this needs to be a two-way activity and so jobs can
1:39:421 hour, 39 minutes, 42 secondsbe created in both countries right I think there's an opportunity to we talked about supply chain resilience and needing to diversify sources Etc and
1:39:511 hour, 39 minutes, 51 secondscompanies are always looking particularly exacerbated by the pandemic so I think there's an opportunity for countries that you aren't always talking
1:40:001 hour, 40 minutesabout to participate in that process depending on where they have an advantage great okay sir go ahead
1:40:081 hour, 40 minutes, 8 secondsyou've been waiting patiently thank you Aaron Michael Gill I'm chairman of the industry trade advisory committee for intellectual property
1:40:171 hour, 40 minutes, 17 secondsum in the context of rules of the road unfortunately we've seen a pretty bad deterioration of the IP environment
1:40:261 hour, 40 minutes, 26 secondsglobally especially for Innovative companies like Corning and many others um
1:40:341 hour, 40 minutes, 34 secondsthe question is to sort of promote this sort of economic diploma diplomacy environment
1:40:421 hour, 40 minutes, 42 secondsa lot of the companies that we represent need access to Capital opportunity and expertise and having those three things
1:40:511 hour, 40 minutes, 51 secondsin a environment where the rules of the road and the playing field is level couldn't be more important
1:40:591 hour, 40 minutes, 59 secondssort of I'd love to hear some perspective on where you think we're going in that
1:41:061 hour, 41 minutes, 6 secondsdirection because from folks that focus on Innovation and IP that environment's getting unfortunately
1:41:131 hour, 41 minutes, 13 secondsworse and getting access to those critical three buckets of resources is getting harder because the risk of
1:41:211 hour, 41 minutes, 21 secondsengaging overseas is increasing want to take that on
1:41:291 hour, 41 minutes, 29 secondsum let me start uh I would note uh in the case of china IP has gone from our number one concern to number 10 11 12.
1:41:361 hour, 41 minutes, 36 secondsuh the environment is much improved it's not perfect uh a lot to be done still but uh as uh other countries have more
1:41:451 hour, 41 minutes, 45 secondsIP they're in enforcement improves um and certainly we've seen that uh in in the case of China in accordance to
1:41:541 hour, 41 minutes, 54 secondsour statistical data our surveys um where uh uh Innovative companies can
1:42:021 hour, 42 minutes, 2 secondsget capital from uh you know that's a broader question that I think probably um Kathy
1:42:091 hour, 42 minutes, 9 secondsor um Michelle would be much better at the night well I
1:42:161 hour, 42 minutes, 16 secondsput all in lots of places I mean and uh in fact you know there's a lot of
1:42:241 hour, 42 minutes, 24 secondsventure capital that's seeking good Investments right now and so you just don't I mean I'm not sure I know
1:42:321 hour, 42 minutes, 32 secondsprecisely what you if there's a specific country you're talking about or um yeah the the context
1:42:411 hour, 42 minutes, 41 secondsum if you think about sort of the trips waiver at the U um at the WTO if you think about U.S giving a precedent for
1:42:501 hour, 42 minutes, 50 secondsthe misappropriation of U.S technology if you think about the advancement of India's sort of you know the the
1:43:001 hour, 43 minutesgenerics uh industry to some extent and the narrative around IP harming Innovation that's never taken hold more
1:43:091 hour, 43 minutes, 9 secondsbroadly than it is today and the economics that go along with that are going outside of the country but I
1:43:181 hour, 43 minutes, 18 secondsapologize if it's a little too in the weeds for the so I foreign it's not in the weeds but it's really
1:43:271 hour, 43 minutes, 27 secondsthe effect of a global disaster and so what you really need are strong IP chapters a strong
1:43:351 hour, 43 minutes, 35 secondsintellectual property agreements in the various forum and you've got to work hard to build that agreement because people have just suffered through
1:43:431 hour, 43 minutes, 43 secondsmassive deaths in their country and they're thinking if only we'd had these drugs if only we'd have this faster that may not be the answer but you're just
1:43:521 hour, 43 minutes, 52 secondsgoing to have to work it through and so for example the IP chapter in usmca is a very good chapter and so we need to try
1:44:001 hour, 44 minutesthat's one of the good reasons we should be in some of these other agreements getting other countries to commit to
1:44:091 hour, 44 minutes, 9 secondsCommon understandings and the only way we're going to make progress is if we start again investing in these common
1:44:151 hour, 44 minutes, 15 secondsunderstandings especially in areas where the United States is so strong like intellectual property
1:44:231 hour, 44 minutes, 23 secondsokay there's another question online and it's directed at Kathy but I think anybody can take it on as well thank you Kathy for bringing up the work of local
1:44:321 hour, 44 minutes, 32 secondsgovernment and the work of promoting our companies and supporting our companies looking to do business abroad would you or the panel have suggestions on how
1:44:391 hour, 44 minutes, 39 secondselse local governments here in the U.S can work more effectively to promote our companies abroad and this is from Manish goyal at the San Francisco office of
1:44:471 hour, 44 minutes, 47 secondsEconomic and Workforce Development so she's I mean others may have thoughts too I
1:44:551 hour, 44 minutes, 55 secondsmean one thing I would say is there have been some mayors that have just been extraordinarily effective
1:45:031 hour, 45 minutes, 3 secondsmayor of Houston mayor of Greenville South Carolina I mean there's there's a number of them around the country who
1:45:111 hour, 45 minutes, 11 secondshave just been hugely effective so one thing I would say is talk to them because they've obviously you know
1:45:191 hour, 45 minutes, 19 secondswith not a lot of resources done a whole whole lot so and there's you know there's all kinds of organizations of Mayors and things too that you can join
1:45:271 hour, 45 minutes, 27 secondsinto that are looking at those kinds of things so to me it's partly learning from others you know what they've done
1:45:351 hour, 45 minutes, 35 secondsthat's super right the mayor seemed again from that program we we did the mayor seem to talk a lot and share best practices and there's a lot of really
1:45:431 hour, 45 minutes, 43 secondsgood experience there um I presume the Commerce foreign commercial service or the Commerce department has somebody in San Francisco
1:45:521 hour, 45 minutes, 52 secondsprobably as well I'm guessing there's definitely somebody in LA because we had a person I didn't know we had you know people who speak fluent Mandarin who are
1:46:011 hour, 46 minutes, 1 secondin La promoting U.S business in China it's incredible but so presumably there is in San Francisco I think
1:46:071 hour, 46 minutes, 7 secondsyeah certainly and those to me are the the obvious ones but I would also say that a number of foreign countries are
1:46:141 hour, 46 minutes, 14 secondssetting up offices in major capitals so I would seek those out as potential Partners as well because they've
1:46:211 hour, 46 minutes, 21 secondsidentified your Market your region your city as potentially uh hub for activity
1:46:281 hour, 46 minutes, 28 secondsor increased investment and exports so I think that that's one group that we haven't talked about but it's kind of
1:46:351 hour, 46 minutes, 35 secondstaking a page out of out of our book the U.S book and we're seeing a number of foreign countries do that great okay ma'am you've been waiting patiently yeah
1:46:431 hour, 46 minutes, 43 secondsthank you I'm Mary tarnovka and I was a long-term State Department economic officer served in a lot of countries
1:46:511 hour, 46 minutes, 51 secondsmostly in Asia places like New Delhi Taipei Shanghai Seoul and most recently
1:46:591 hour, 46 minutes, 59 secondsin Ho Chi Minh City so I definitely agree with Craig's comments about look at where the growth is look at where the development is and where companies are
1:47:071 hour, 47 minutes, 7 secondslooking to diversify Supply chains one suggestion I would make when you're looking at how do you get those
1:47:151 hour, 47 minutes, 15 secondsresources leverage with the private sector Private Business associations my last overseas
1:47:221 hour, 47 minutes, 22 secondspost was at U.S consul General in Ho Chi Minh City I moved to become the executive director of amcham and I will
1:47:291 hour, 47 minutes, 29 secondssay that that kind of partnership which we had with the U.S Mission and which I
1:47:361 hour, 47 minutes, 36 secondshad had in a number of posts as an honorary M Chan liaison I think is a really critical way that the U.S
1:47:431 hour, 47 minutes, 43 secondsgovernment Commerce State and the agricultural Department can really leverage your reach and I guess that's
1:47:511 hour, 47 minutes, 51 secondsmy other question is where is agriculture in all of this because overseas it is a key component of any
1:47:591 hour, 47 minutes, 59 secondseconomic cluster working group and in many countries I've served it's one of the top U.S exports is that part of your
1:48:081 hour, 48 minutes, 8 secondscommercial diplomacy initiative I was delighted to hear how State Commerce you know and hopefully UST and other
1:48:151 hour, 48 minutes, 15 secondsagencies are working more closely is the Department of Agriculture part of that effort here because every governor
1:48:231 hour, 48 minutes, 23 secondswho comes that's top of their agenda right now really good question and we've gotten through a whole hour without actually mentioning you know Agriculture and the
1:48:311 hour, 48 minutes, 31 secondsforeign agricultural service and so forth how do they play in this space the short answer is that the foreign agricultural service is a very wealthy
1:48:401 hour, 48 minutes, 40 secondssister uh that that we all adore uh because uh they have more resources uh
1:48:471 hour, 48 minutes, 47 secondsand are very targeted at specific commodity groups and have a very very
1:48:541 hour, 48 minutes, 54 secondsstrong domestic base uh to keep that going um and U.S agricultural exports have
1:49:021 hour, 49 minutes, 2 secondsbenefited as a result by far the world's largest exporter of agricultural goods and China was the largest market in last
1:49:111 hour, 49 minutes, 11 secondsyear 44 billion dollars of U.S agricultural goods and um uh we Envy their financial resources
1:49:221 hour, 49 minutes, 22 secondsdefinitely I believe the Congressional people who put this bill together in
1:49:301 hour, 49 minutes, 30 secondsenvisioned USDA to being part of this uh economic diplomacy action committee that they would set up because they do
1:49:371 hour, 49 minutes, 37 secondsrecognize that but but I just want I want to note that of course some of the main blockages that our exporters face are often
1:49:461 hour, 49 minutes, 46 secondsphytosanitary and uh sentiments against genetically modified uh products which is the kind of
1:49:551 hour, 49 minutes, 55 secondsregulatory conversations you have to have with other governments and the kind of agreements you need to negotiate with
1:50:021 hour, 50 minutes, 2 secondsthem to allow those kind of innovative project products to continue to be sold and traded again yes USDA is a key
1:50:111 hour, 50 minutes, 11 secondspartner and but they they need to work with their Partners in Commerce and state to
1:50:191 hour, 50 minutes, 19 secondsreally keep sustaining this growth can I mention one area that we just yes if you've got 10 seconds of anything we
1:50:261 hour, 50 minutes, 26 secondshaven't talked about really really quick one thing that sort of passed by as we talked to is Workforce Development and if we think of some of these
1:50:361 hour, 50 minutes, 36 secondsspecialized sectors and if we want to strengthen certain sectors even from a security perspective but also from a Prosperity perspective you actually need
1:50:441 hour, 50 minutes, 44 secondsto invest in your workforces at home but also your partners have to invest in those workforces if they're going to
1:50:521 hour, 50 minutes, 52 secondshave systems that are compatible to yours especially when we move into technology telecommunications digital
1:50:581 hour, 50 minutes, 58 secondsarea and this is a this is a field in which the United States is not very developed and strong we have individual
1:51:071 hour, 51 minutes, 7 secondscases of successes those tend to be local with Mayors and governors and local universities and local and
1:51:151 hour, 51 minutes, 15 secondsbusinesses present locally working together but we haven't figured out how to learn from those experiences share them and to make them International Even
1:51:231 hour, 51 minutes, 23 secondsin our most integrated markets across North America so I just wanted to to flag that we have to train we have to
1:51:321 hour, 51 minutes, 32 secondsfind ways to make make sure people are getting trained and have the capacity to take advantage of these evolving markets
1:51:391 hour, 51 minutes, 39 secondsaround the world okay any final benedictions or many other panelists okay I think we covered a lot
1:51:471 hour, 51 minutes, 47 secondsof ground and maybe encroached on the next panel's uh Mission as well but but on the other hand we probably didn't cover everything certainly not in detail
1:51:551 hour, 51 minutes, 55 secondsso you've got an opportunity in the next panel to explore some of these issues further so if you could uh please join me in thanking our terrific panel for there
1:52:031 hour, 52 minutes, 3 secondsthank you all and I believe unless Phil tells me otherwise we reconvene in five minutes or two
1:52:101 hour, 52 minutes, 10 secondsminutes three five okay are you going to say something
1:52:131 hour, 52 minutes, 13 seconds[Music]
1:52:211 hour, 52 minutes, 21 secondsoh
1:52:511 hour, 52 minutes, 51 seconds[Music]
1:52:551 hour, 52 minutes, 55 secondsforeign
1:53:231 hour, 53 minutes, 23 seconds[Music]
1:53:431 hour, 53 minutes, 43 secondsthank you
1:54:061 hour, 54 minutes, 6 secondsforeign
1:54:481 hour, 54 minutes, 48 secondsforeign
1:54:581 hour, 54 minutes, 58 seconds[Music]
1:55:311 hour, 55 minutes, 31 secondsforeign
1:55:321 hour, 55 minutes, 32 seconds[Music]
1:56:161 hour, 56 minutes, 16 secondsthank you
1:56:341 hour, 56 minutes, 34 seconds[Music]
1:56:441 hour, 56 minutes, 44 secondsforeign
1:57:171 hour, 57 minutes, 17 secondsforeign
1:57:451 hour, 57 minutes, 45 secondsthank you foreign
1:58:101 hour, 58 minutes, 10 seconds[Music]
1:58:271 hour, 58 minutes, 27 secondsforeign
1:59:081 hour, 59 minutes, 8 secondsmore or less if you can take your seats and if you're out there in the in the atrium if you can come back in that would be good
1:59:191 hour, 59 minutes, 19 secondswe'll give everybody an no one's paying attention to me out there but uh that's all right uh we're going to get
1:59:261 hour, 59 minutes, 26 secondsstarted let me um before I turn over the panel let me just say we just got a note from Congressman allred's office saying that unfortunately he has a personal emergency
1:59:351 hour, 59 minutes, 35 secondsand is going to not be able to join us today which I'm very sorry to hear I hope everything works out all right for
1:59:421 hour, 59 minutes, 42 secondshim we've added uh Dale takarski to join the panel so he's now been downgraded from the previous upgrade but that helps
Chapter 10: Closing panel session
1:59:521 hour, 59 minutes, 52 secondsfill out the panel and I'm going to turn it over to Ambassador Doherty to introduce everybody and and the topic great uh well thank you everyone and
2:00:002 hoursit's always hard to follow such a great panel but I I think we've got a lot to pick up on it is unfortunate that representative Albert didn't join us
2:00:072 hours, 7 secondsbecause I would have been very curious to hear why they thought cabinet was so important the US Congress but as as previous speakers mentioned it was a
2:00:152 hours, 15 secondsbipartisan support there were four Republican co-sponsors and three Democratic co-sponsors of which representative alright was one of them
2:00:242 hours, 24 secondsbut I have a great panel here and I know we're going to solve the whole issue of commercial diplomacy and uh and give you some words of wisdom to walk away with
2:00:312 hours, 31 secondsbut let me introduce my fellow panelists and Dale thank you for being a great infielder a utility player you know it's great to be joining us again
2:00:402 hours, 40 secondsum to my left is Ambassador Chuck Hub he is the CEO of an investment firm and has extensive international business experience as a former CEO or CEO of
2:00:492 hours, 49 secondsseveral large International companies Walt Disney Development arita Corporation and Penn Central he has also been on the boards of nine publicly held
2:00:572 hours, 57 secondscompanies Ambassador Cobb was the assistant secretary and under Secretary of Commerce and ambassador of Iceland he was also on the board of OPEC and an
2:01:052 hours, 1 minute, 5 secondsex-official member of exum's board in addition his wife Ambassador Sue Cobb is also with us is the former U.S ambassador Judah Mega Ambassador Cobb
2:01:132 hours, 1 minute, 13 secondscreated and endowed an annual ten thousand dollar State Department award given to the queer U.S ambassador doing the best job in commercial advocacy
2:01:222 hours, 1 minute, 22 secondswe have with us Kathleen Ambrose who is a lawyer who has worked as a senior leader in political campaigns in the U.S government as an international trade
2:01:292 hours, 1 minute, 29 secondsCouncil and Deputy general counsel in the Department of Commerce as a senior White House aide as the chief of staff to a member of the House of Representative and head of global of
2:01:382 hours, 1 minute, 38 secondsgovernment Affairs for four multinational companies she recently retired this year from TE Connectivity a
2:01:442 hours, 1 minute, 44 secondsswiss-based global electronics company uh we have Ambassador Bob Sakura has had a four decades career in the state
2:01:522 hours, 1 minute, 52 secondsdepartment as an economic officer in Washington he was a deputy assistant secretary EB and principal Deputy assistant secretary in the state
2:01:592 hours, 1 minute, 59 secondsDepartment's new energy Bureau his overseas assignments include lower income developing countries such as Yemen and and was posed as such economic
2:02:072 hours, 2 minutes, 7 secondsand an economic Ministry in Berlin and Tokyo he now works in energy related issues in the private sector and is a professor of diplomatic practice at American University Dale we've already
2:02:162 hours, 2 minutes, 16 secondsintroduced you so I don't think you need to do it again um but uh um and I'm Kathleen Doherty I was the U.S ambassador to Cyprus I was
2:02:232 hours, 2 minutes, 23 secondsan economic officer and I mostly my 25 of my 30 years at the stage when I was in economic positions and I was a deputy
2:02:302 hours, 2 minutes, 30 secondsassistant secretary for Europe and did a lot of negotiations on the ill-fated t-tip so uh so with that I thought it would
2:02:382 hours, 2 minutes, 38 secondstake um kind of Tony's challenge the offense versus defense or offense and defense
2:02:452 hours, 2 minutes, 45 secondsapproach to commercial diplomacy we are kind of there's also been phrase we're in a battlefield for markets we're in a battlefield for influence I'm going to
2:02:532 hours, 2 minutes, 53 secondsuse a little bit more positive then and be proactive versus deep reactive so I would like to ask each of the panelists how do you
2:03:012 hours, 3 minutes, 1 secondenvision this proactive approach to commercial diplomacy how do we take what we're already doing and we're doing well we've all acknowledged some of the shot
2:03:092 hours, 3 minutes, 9 secondsclimbings what's our next step and and so Chuck I'll turn it over to you first
2:03:152 hours, 3 minutes, 15 secondswell I agree with uh Tony that we do a a very good job on defense
2:03:232 hours, 3 minutes, 23 secondsand and so I guess I disagreed with the one question that we weren't doing enough in intellectual property and and
2:03:302 hours, 3 minutes, 30 secondsother policy areas so so I think we're doing a pretty good job but I also agree with Tony we're doing not as good a job
2:03:382 hours, 3 minutes, 38 secondsoffensively and and I liked his analogy to sports because I I think uh
2:03:452 hours, 3 minutes, 45 secondsAmerica at this time uh hasn't put commercial diplomacy at the highest
2:03:532 hours, 3 minutes, 53 secondslevel of of our national policy so I'm disappointed uh that our last two presidents a a both a republican a
2:04:022 hours, 4 minutes, 2 secondsDemocrat have not put commercial diplomacy at the top of their agenda have not LED trade missions as was
2:04:122 hours, 4 minutes, 12 secondspointed out the the the presidents of all of our major con competitors those presidents have led
2:04:212 hours, 4 minutes, 21 secondstrade missions and are and they send a signal to the whole country that this is important in addition to sending an
2:04:292 hours, 4 minutes, 29 secondsimportant signal to the rest of the bureaucracy and I'm disappointed in the last two administrations Republican and
2:04:352 hours, 4 minutes, 35 secondsDemocrat there have not been the trade missions that there were before and I agree with the comments of the last
2:04:432 hours, 4 minutes, 43 secondspanel that that Governors and Mayors have have entered the void because there
2:04:512 hours, 4 minutes, 51 secondshasn't been uh the leadership by the last two administrations that I think
2:04:572 hours, 4 minutes, 57 secondsprevious administrations have have given commercial diplomacy in an offensive sense so I personally am delighted that
2:05:072 hours, 5 minutes, 7 secondsCongress by a a 40 to 5 vote for H.R 1704 which was
2:05:172 hours, 5 minutes, 17 secondsthe basis for the eventual Congress passing the champion of cabinet and um
2:05:282 hours, 5 minutes, 28 secondsand and so Congress has spoken this is a high priority and and in instructions a
2:05:352 hours, 5 minutes, 35 secondsmandate to to the previous administration when the law was passed and the president Administration
2:05:422 hours, 5 minutes, 42 secondsuh who unfortunately have have have done several good things as we heard yet from the under secretary
2:05:512 hours, 5 minutes, 51 secondsum and from Dale today yes we've made some improvements but there's so much more improvements to go and and I'm
2:05:582 hours, 5 minutes, 58 secondshopeful that that um that that our president uh and all of our cabinet give this a higher priority
2:06:072 hours, 6 minutes, 7 secondsthe priority that it needs um thank you for the for the question I think I'm a little bit of a contrarian
2:06:152 hours, 6 minutes, 15 secondshere I would say two things one is I'm going to quote Martin indic who just wrote a new book and he says
2:06:232 hours, 6 minutes, 23 secondsdon't be so timid I mean we are just so timid as a country we are timid to acknowledge the relationship
2:06:302 hours, 6 minutes, 30 secondsan unnecessary relationship between business and the government and we are timid about going out in front and
2:06:372 hours, 6 minutes, 37 secondstouting Deals and you know Macomb was not timid I mean he just wasn't um and we probably
2:06:452 hours, 6 minutes, 45 secondsum could use a little bit of that Moxie so I think that's a good admonition and it's a little bit of pulling together the strands of all the things that were
2:06:522 hours, 6 minutes, 52 secondssaid in the previous panel and what the Ambassador just said but I think there's a Converse part of it which is the contrarian part of me having been inside
2:07:012 hours, 7 minutes, 1 secondmultilateral multinational companies for a good huge portion of my career after my government career
2:07:082 hours, 7 minutes, 8 secondscompanies don't have a clue how to do this and let's be honest about that I can of the four companies I work for I
2:07:162 hours, 7 minutes, 16 secondscan go through a name on one hand each in each of those companies the number of people who have some sophistication about commercial
2:07:242 hours, 7 minutes, 24 secondsdiplomacy the ability of the US government to help in achieving markets advancing markets investing in markets
2:07:312 hours, 7 minutes, 31 secondsexpanding their markets and I don't feel that we as the business community and I'm just recently retired from that
2:07:392 hours, 7 minutes, 39 secondsbusiness Community have the necessary high level pressure and push so that President Biden or president Trump or
2:07:462 hours, 7 minutes, 46 secondsPresident Obama would actually take it very seriously who do they think is there is their peer they think it's the CEO of the company the CEOs of the
2:07:542 hours, 7 minutes, 54 secondscompany if they spend three minutes on this in a year it's a lot of their time they have lots of Demands on their time and we as a business Community don't
2:08:032 hours, 8 minutes, 3 secondsmake it the priority to put the pressure and therefore get the results from the top of the US government and so I think in the end of the day Martin indicts
2:08:122 hours, 8 minutes, 12 secondsadmonition is really important and it comes down to symbolism in some ways the symbolism of the CEOs investing their time and then getting someone like bite
2:08:202 hours, 8 minutes, 20 secondsand saying well wait a minute I'm listening to what the country needs in terms of business success so I think those are two halves that bring together
2:08:282 hours, 8 minutes, 28 secondssome of the strands we heard in other parts of today's conversation I think it's a great Point Kathleen and um I'm going to follow up with that later
2:08:362 hours, 8 minutes, 36 secondsum I know most of us who have been ambassadors have been sometimes surprised when companies have come into our door with their level of preparedness about the country or market
2:08:452 hours, 8 minutes, 45 secondsand so I've all I had a working assumption when I was a more Junior Diplomat that corporations are more sophisticated in their approach and and
2:08:532 hours, 8 minutes, 53 secondsthey weren't so I do think we make a lot of generalizations and assumptions and I thank you for bringing that up Bob yeah I want to I think you come back on that
2:09:012 hours, 9 minutes, 1 secondone too um I think coming back to your your question Kathleen I think the big thing is be entrepreneurial
2:09:092 hours, 9 minutes, 9 secondsum when I was listening to the presentation earlier and was applying okay there you know you do the calculation and you've got so much money
2:09:172 hours, 9 minutes, 17 secondsand here's the red line and you're below it well I don't think this is a news flash when you're the economic commercial officer
2:09:252 hours, 9 minutes, 25 secondsin Yemen you're not really expecting to be above the line okay yeah maybe in a more extreme case but you could be in Iraq you could be in an Albanian you
2:09:332 hours, 9 minutes, 33 secondscould be in Austria and you might not necessarily be where you want to be on that line and so one of the things which I found both more was in the department and
2:09:412 hours, 9 minutes, 41 secondswhile I was an econ off overseas but also even as Ambassador is you've got to be entrepreneurial you've got to be saying okay I'm not going to be in the magic line where everybody's going to be
2:09:492 hours, 9 minutes, 49 secondsdropping into me like I was in Tokyo um but what do we have here what are the opportunities for U.S business and
2:09:582 hours, 9 minutes, 58 secondsgetting those out the other thing is being engaged with the local government they don't have to know you fell below the line
2:10:062 hours, 10 minutes, 6 secondsso get in there and and push but then maybe this comes back at that point don't be timid don't be a jerk
2:10:132 hours, 10 minutes, 13 secondsbut don't be timid and sort of you know look for those opportunities that you can get in there pull your team together both in Washington and overseas between
2:10:232 hours, 10 minutes, 23 secondsthe two frankly and push yeah yeah you know it's it's I think a lot of the elements uh to the answer to
2:10:312 hours, 10 minutes, 31 secondsyour question Kathy or I've been sort of teed up uh in in the room today and and for me uh uh you know Outreach is really
2:10:382 hours, 10 minutes, 38 secondsimportant it's it's not just a whole of government approach to supporting companies it's really a whole of America approach uh when you look around and you
2:10:452 hours, 10 minutes, 45 secondssee the the response that many of our uh what used to be where we used to be the uh the primary trading partner in many countries around the world where China
2:10:532 hours, 10 minutes, 53 secondshas taken over that uh that role over the last uh last uh dozen years or so uh you you see a desire uh for for us to be
2:11:022 hours, 11 minutes, 2 secondsthere but we're not there so we've got to show up the old saying you know half the half of it or seventy percent of it is showing up we've got to show up and I think some of the things that were
2:11:092 hours, 11 minutes, 9 secondspointed out this morning uh about uh you know getting the governors and the Mayors more engaged in in uh in in in in bringing companies and bringing trade
2:11:182 hours, 11 minutes, 18 secondsmissions to Market we also have to show up with US Government presence in support of them as well and for our folks in uh in San Francisco you know call our call our office please we'll
2:11:262 hours, 11 minutes, 26 secondshave happy to help the mayor in the economic development organization just throwing that back in from the last panel but yeah it's it's all about showing up it's really about a whole of
2:11:342 hours, 11 minutes, 34 secondsAmerica approach and I I'm I'm actually quite uh enthusiastic about where the direction the capda has has been leading
2:11:422 hours, 11 minutes, 42 secondsus uh because it is drawing the attention of of senior officials in across across agencies including the financial uh side of our our equation
2:11:502 hours, 11 minutes, 50 secondswhich is very very important as well and we've got to we've got to do more to incorporate that and make sure it moves at the speed of business so that our companies can't compete but showing up
2:11:582 hours, 11 minutes, 58 secondsis is key just two comments one on the mayor and Governor issue there is a new office in the state department on
2:12:062 hours, 12 minutes, 6 secondssub-national diplomacy headed by Ambassador Nina hajjigan who was the deputy mayor of Los Angeles and she was involved in trade issues at nla and now
2:12:152 hours, 12 minutes, 15 secondsthey're in the state department and I think what you're starting to see is this evolution of a federal agency relationship with the state governments
2:12:232 hours, 12 minutes, 23 secondsor city governments and it's it's something that I think is very impossible if it needs to be more developed as a brand new office but I
2:12:302 hours, 12 minutes, 30 secondsthink this is an indication and how do you work I think federal agencies are so Washington focused we don't realize that we have a whole network behind us that
2:12:382 hours, 12 minutes, 38 secondsneed to be utilized and I do think some of the things you said one of the other issues that I also would like to hear for your opinion is we talk about the
2:12:462 hours, 12 minutes, 46 secondswhole government and we've talked about the Department of Agriculture obviously Commerce and state but there's other players when we talk whole government
2:12:532 hours, 12 minutes, 53 secondsand just my own personal experience we haven't talked about the intelligence services and I do remember in one of the
2:13:022 hours, 13 minutes, 2 secondsposts in which I served in um the intelligence Services were aware of some Market activity by other companies
2:13:102 hours, 13 minutes, 10 secondsfor our non-us companies and it was a revolution a revelation that that they don't really care about Commerce and
2:13:172 hours, 13 minutes, 17 secondsCommercial activities and or maybe should they but as we talk about a whole government approach should we bring in and really think about its Treasury Department the intelligence Services DOD
2:13:262 hours, 13 minutes, 26 secondsall other government agencies to have this kind of momentum that we really need to make it a priority so I I welcome anyone's comments on that about
2:13:342 hours, 13 minutes, 34 secondswhen you think of whole government we think traditionally if State and commerce but we need to broaden that much more well all that uh
2:13:432 hours, 13 minutes, 43 secondstake on the issue of XM which is a part of America's
2:13:512 hours, 13 minutes, 51 secondsportfolio of of strength hopefully and unfortunately
2:13:582 hours, 13 minutes, 58 secondsthe tag of corporate welfare has been attached to to XM and to the former OPEC and other
2:14:082 hours, 14 minutes, 8 secondsparts of government that do financing and which I think is totally unfair and and unwise because if
2:14:182 hours, 14 minutes, 18 secondsyou do a return on investment analysis um you will find that that XM not only
2:14:272 hours, 14 minutes, 27 secondsmakes money um from the from the interest rates it charges but the jobs it creates uh it's not
2:14:372 hours, 14 minutes, 37 secondscorporate welfare it it is one of the few parts of government that that can demonstrate a a good rate of return
2:14:452 hours, 14 minutes, 45 secondsand um and so um I think I think that whole concept of
2:14:522 hours, 14 minutes, 52 secondsreturn on investment that I know a number I know your agency certainly does that it foreign commercial service it
2:15:002 hours, 15 minutescontinues to how many how many jobs have we created for per dollar and I know I've seen those reports and they're very
2:15:072 hours, 15 minutes, 7 secondsimpressive and and so one of the answers that I would also make in the earlier
2:15:132 hours, 15 minutes, 13 secondspanel the whole discussion was uh do we need a hundred uh additional commercial officers
2:15:222 hours, 15 minutes, 22 secondswell I am sure a return on investment analysis would show that that yes that would make
2:15:302 hours, 15 minutes, 30 secondsmoney and yes that will make money for the American taxpayer and uh and so
2:15:362 hours, 15 minutes, 36 secondsyou know that concept uh seems to be to be very important and and because the
2:15:442 hours, 15 minutes, 44 secondspublic understands that so government bureaucrats where they're trying to justify their departments need to do
2:15:512 hours, 15 minutes, 51 secondsthat more often I want to sort of build this thing Chuck said but I also want to come back to this broader question about basically
2:15:582 hours, 15 minutes, 58 secondswhole a government country team approach War Story when I was Ambassador in Azerbaijan there was an offer I think
2:16:052 hours, 16 minutes, 5 secondsfor a 240 million dollar satellite us had the technology us had the package we had even done the earlier satellite
2:16:132 hours, 16 minutes, 13 secondsbut this was that period when XM was not authorized and so there was no exim so what happened we did the deal the deal got split
2:16:222 hours, 16 minutes, 22 secondsbetween the U.S and Canada now again I'm from upstate New York I like Canada it's a good place but come on we literally
2:16:292 hours, 16 minutes, 29 secondsshot ourselves in the foot so that is that much money the export that was lost in the United States those were jobs lost in the United States we didn't even
2:16:372 hours, 16 minutes, 37 secondswe weren't able to compete at all in the launch thing that went to the French so this is why these agencies are important why we need to work on them
2:16:452 hours, 16 minutes, 45 secondstogether but I think coming back to Kathleen's question one of the and this goes back also to the earlier uh discussion about uh
2:16:542 hours, 16 minutes, 54 secondshow an embassy can really help set level the playing field pulling in the information that you get
2:17:012 hours, 17 minutes, 1 secondfrom all the the people that post and working together with all the people who post is really important I mean we never even think about like
2:17:092 hours, 17 minutes, 9 secondsour even the state department our Consular service and what it does for the business Community I mean they're the ones who handle the Visas if you want to get somebody to come to the US
2:17:162 hours, 17 minutes, 16 secondsor you're trying to get people out and or business people who are caught in in some sort of problem who are arrested someplace they're the ones who are
2:17:242 hours, 17 minutes, 24 secondsworking on this but we need to be thinking about and we need to be sort of getting this point across to the other agencies that what DOD is doing is just
2:17:312 hours, 17 minutes, 31 secondsas important as what U.S what's the Department of Agriculture is doing or what Justice is doing and and try to sort of pull this together a lot of this
2:17:392 hours, 17 minutes, 39 secondsFalls unfortunately on the Ambassador and sort of pulling that sense together in the field I think it's easier in the field than it is here in Washington but
2:17:472 hours, 17 minutes, 47 secondsmaybe that's also something that needs to each kind of work through as we follow through on the implementation of capital yeah I mean in one of the posts I served
Chapter 11: Final wrap up
2:17:552 hours, 17 minutes, 55 secondsat we had 22 U.S government agencies um at post it would have been great if everyone felt commercial diplomacy was part of their remit and how do you
2:18:032 hours, 18 minutes, 3 secondsinterpret and led with the challenges and Market access you were facing or any of these issues and I think part of it is set by the country team and the
2:18:102 hours, 18 minutes, 10 secondscountry team is the interagency uh group at an embassy chaired by the chief admission but it does start at the chief commission instructing everyone at post
2:18:192 hours, 18 minutes, 19 secondsthis is a high priority speaking of Chief Admissions and and I'm one of the issues that is a chronic problem and we
2:18:272 hours, 18 minutes, 27 secondshave and it seems to be getting worse is that the a lot of our countries do not have ambassadors right now if I seem to remember that some of countries such as
2:18:362 hours, 18 minutes, 36 secondsthe Italy Colombia Kuwait um maybe Saudi Arabia even have nominees or have not had no nominees yet for the
2:18:442 hours, 18 minutes, 44 secondsposts an ambassador is is an is an essential person we have very qualified and talented dcms or acting ambassadors but
2:18:532 hours, 18 minutes, 53 secondsI do think as a symbol and as a in as ability to influence decision making the absence of an ambassador is a real
2:19:002 hours, 19 minutesproblem and I'd like to have your thoughts about it as as as all members of the panel how do we deal with that elephant in the room when
2:19:092 hours, 19 minutes, 9 secondsyou're a key person in the morning in the embassy is not there
2:19:142 hours, 19 minutes, 14 seconds[Laughter]
2:19:192 hours, 19 minutes, 19 secondsfor comment I I think it's a problem when there isn't the Ambassador we all understand that but I think it is back
2:19:252 hours, 19 minutes, 25 secondsto the an underlying problem I see which is we want to advocate for business we want to see the interagency process work
2:19:332 hours, 19 minutes, 33 secondsuh more thoroughly but there's an overlay that we have to remember which is the new administration every time there's a new Administration even if
2:19:422 hours, 19 minutes, 42 secondsit's a continuation it's the second four years of their foreign policy attitude and that foreign policy attitude
2:19:482 hours, 19 minutes, 48 secondstranslates down again it's a symbol but it translates down into something like not Staffing a country that is not
2:19:562 hours, 19 minutes, 56 secondsdeemed uh so important it's not you know they staffed certain countries right away but the other ones sort of get lost in the shuffle and so I think that
2:20:052 hours, 20 minutes, 5 secondsforeign policy overlay is something again that companies really grapple with they don't understand it there are very
2:20:122 hours, 20 minutes, 12 secondsfew business people who who are who pick their heads up and look at the broader world or the geopolitical structure or
2:20:192 hours, 20 minutes, 19 secondsmoves or Trends because their job is to produce whatever product they're producing and sell it and and Report um their numbers you know every week and
2:20:282 hours, 20 minutes, 28 secondsevery month um so you're dealing with a population that doesn't understand that Stratosphere of the other foreign policy
2:20:352 hours, 20 minutes, 35 secondsissues and I think those foreign policy issues translate down the very specific example I have at the moment is dealing with China and I'm sorry Craig's not
2:20:432 hours, 20 minutes, 43 secondshere I'm out of the U.S China Business Council um uh Amelia at the moment since I retired
2:20:512 hours, 20 minutes, 51 secondsbut basically let's be honest the US government is not advocating for business in China at the moment they're not advocating for U.S businesses to
2:20:592 hours, 20 minutes, 59 secondsinvest in China build plants employ more people they don't they don't want you to do that I mean that's that's their foreign policy and
2:21:082 hours, 21 minutes, 8 secondsso you can go and see the best people at the U.S embassy in Beijing and they were the best in the world often um and their hands are tied so the
2:21:162 hours, 21 minutes, 16 secondsforeign policy overlay is something that is extremely important and that gets down to how are the agencies the intelligence agencies and all the other
2:21:252 hours, 21 minutes, 25 secondsagencies feeding into that process so that there's a counterbalance between kind of an overarching uh Theory and the
2:21:332 hours, 21 minutes, 33 secondsand the everyday practicality of what the what the interagency process is telling you we're losing out to competition in this case we invited the
2:21:402 hours, 21 minutes, 40 secondscompetition to help us lose out in Bob's example of Canada but that that there's this they're by Play Between the regular
2:21:482 hours, 21 minutes, 48 secondsapparatus of the government and this overlay of a new Administration and a new philosophy and that makes it much more complicated for businesses to
2:21:562 hours, 21 minutes, 56 secondsnavigate and they're not sophisticated enough to navigate it without some signal from the government to help them out yeah just on that and then Bob I'm
2:22:052 hours, 22 minutes, 5 secondsgoing to turn to you because you've also been in very countries that have been sometimes in the cross areas of U.S administration's policies I think about
2:22:122 hours, 22 minutes, 12 secondsRussia and all the US investment in Russia that that for both economic and political pressures pulled out of Russia
2:22:192 hours, 22 minutes, 19 secondsand again that they were buffeted by rightfully I mean by what was happening and they should not have been in Russia but it is actually a problem now when
2:22:272 hours, 22 minutes, 27 secondsyou think about it the geopolitics overlay with economic and Commercial diplomacy and I would like to hear a little bit more thoughts on that Bob um
2:22:352 hours, 22 minutes, 35 secondsyeah yeah well having been Deputy assistant secretary for energy sanctions and commodities
2:22:442 hours, 22 minutes, 44 secondsas well as Pete asked for energy there's a little bit of geopolitics that sort of falls into both those portfolios um I want to want to just say one thing
2:22:532 hours, 22 minutes, 53 secondsquickly about the Ambassador thing and then maybe get into this because I think this is an important part in being proactive in how we deal with this
2:23:002 hours, 23 minutesone of the things that we sometimes think about I think what you were talking about you know companies tend to the the CEO wants to talk to the CEO so
2:23:082 hours, 23 minutes, 8 secondsI want to go talk to the Ambassador well there's no Ambassador here oh there's a deputy okay okay what if cool that's not
2:23:162 hours, 23 minutes, 16 secondsnecessarily seen well I think by our companies it is certainly not seen well overseas
2:23:232 hours, 23 minutes, 23 secondsI mean part of the problem reality maybe is the countries have kind of gotten used to us they know when there was a change of administrations
2:23:302 hours, 23 minutes, 30 secondsthere is going to be an interactive particularly in posts where you have political ambassadors um I came in as an ambassador not to but
2:23:392 hours, 23 minutes, 39 secondsactually I replaced a political Ambassador but it was 11 months between dick leaving post and my coming of the post
2:23:472 hours, 23 minutes, 47 secondsand that was to Azerbaijan okay so then you're trying to pick someone for a high profile post now if you're India and you're in the Indian
2:23:552 hours, 23 minutes, 55 secondsgovernment and we're talking about how important India is in general how important India is in trade how important India is is a rising economy
2:24:042 hours, 24 minutes, 4 secondsthat is influencing everything and it's two years before you get an ambassador there and there have been
2:24:112 hours, 24 minutes, 11 secondssome great charges there we've known them but they're the charges and what message do the Indians take away from
2:24:192 hours, 24 minutes, 19 secondsthis which is basically are you really caring about us how much Italy and so forth I mean again we're
2:24:262 hours, 24 minutes, 26 secondspicking these are Big posts um I don't think it's necessarily hard to get someone to say gee I want to be Ambassador in Rome but the uh
2:24:342 hours, 24 minutes, 34 secondsuh but I think this is this is this is an important part of this I think again when we get into this other sort of angle on the geostrategic parts of this
2:24:422 hours, 24 minutes, 42 secondsof where policies will change and the crosshairs where we're on today off tomorrow for a good reason I mean that that's a that's a reality and that's
2:24:492 hours, 24 minutes, 49 secondssomething I think again where that's a that's an aspect of our commercial diplomacy we do have to think about because in some cases
2:24:572 hours, 24 minutes, 57 secondsthere are a lot of companies they're going to stay there that you're going to want to have stayed there um Russia's Wars in Ukraine that's sort
2:25:062 hours, 25 minutes, 6 secondsof an off the charts kind of situation I don't think people expected that um that type of thing to come down the
2:25:132 hours, 25 minutes, 13 secondsline again but again but we do get into this problem sometimes with specific Technologies and so forth that can become very hard to get licenses for to
2:25:212 hours, 25 minutes, 21 secondsget the export permissions for eign I agree with everything that's been said yeah one of the things I think what's
2:25:312 hours, 25 minutes, 31 secondsbeen interesting that no one has used the word natural security when we talk about commercial diplomacy we've used Economic Security we use economic
2:25:382 hours, 25 minutes, 38 secondsProsperity we talk about jobs but I think maybe the urgency behind kabda and the urgency by why we have this panel is
2:25:452 hours, 25 minutes, 45 secondsbecause we are seeing it as part of our national security the strength of our commercial diplomacy is hand in hand with our strength as a national security
2:25:542 hours, 25 minutes, 54 secondsand as a global economic and political power I wonder if um if we started using that word and and
2:26:032 hours, 26 minutes, 3 secondsthis is also response to you kind of thing in terms of private sector not understanding what the stakes are at play that may be getting this kind of
2:26:112 hours, 26 minutes, 11 secondsphrasing without being too adversarial and too you know combative in How We Do It framing this as a national security
2:26:182 hours, 26 minutes, 18 secondsissue our strength is an economic as an economy is is is really essential to our future and and how often have we always
2:26:272 hours, 26 minutes, 27 secondssaid where are the Americans we get that all the time where are the Americans and it's where the American ambassador is but where is American companies where is
2:26:342 hours, 26 minutes, 34 secondsAmerican presence and we're losing that ground um and I think as a priority changing the language bit is is going to be
2:26:422 hours, 26 minutes, 42 secondscritical to this yeah yeah I I agree with that statement and and we've agreed that we weren't
2:26:492 hours, 26 minutes, 49 secondsgoing to get into trade policy today but but trade policy is also critical uh to
2:26:572 hours, 26 minutes, 57 secondsour national security and and for us as a country to not have had a new uh Trade
2:27:052 hours, 27 minutes, 5 secondsAgreement uh for the last 10 years and be the only major country in the world
2:27:112 hours, 27 minutes, 11 secondsnot to have had new trade relationships with free trade agreements is is consistent with your point this is a
2:27:212 hours, 27 minutes, 21 secondsnational security issue you anticipated the question that actually was just asked online but uh maybe if I think of some other reactions
2:27:292 hours, 27 minutes, 29 secondsit says how could the U.S pursue a proactive commercial diplomacy well stays at a free trade agreements and keeps weaponizing trade against even
2:27:362 hours, 27 minutes, 36 secondsallies like the EU South Korea and Japan anyone want to tackle that yeah can I make a comment I think this comes
2:27:452 hours, 27 minutes, 45 secondsback to the question of symbolism um you remember if you've been through as some of us in the audience have been through all of these phases of China mfn
2:27:542 hours, 27 minutes, 54 secondsremember how much time we spent on achieving China mfn and getting the WTO passed and getting NAFTA passed and
2:28:012 hours, 28 minutes, 1 secondthere was a conversation that was symbolic practical and galvanizing for galvanizing for and galvanizing against
2:28:102 hours, 28 minutes, 10 secondsthat went on in this country that doesn't exist anymore there's this kind of staccato we are being taken to the
2:28:192 hours, 28 minutes, 19 secondscleaners by you know that's what we heard in the last Administration don't hear it as much now but there's still some of that and so we are missing a
2:28:272 hours, 28 minutes, 27 secondsdimension with the American public so that's why you end up with no agreements no negotiations over the last couple of
2:28:342 hours, 28 minutes, 34 secondsyears we did achieve the U.S Mexico the new version of NAFTA but I think that symbolism of a conversation Mission out
2:28:442 hours, 28 minutes, 44 secondsthere would be enormously to the benefit of advancing something like the pressure on more commercial diplomacy but I would
2:28:542 hours, 28 minutes, 54 secondsum I would uh to question the use of the word National Security if you were to tell the CEO of any of the companies that I
2:29:022 hours, 29 minutes, 2 secondshad previously worked for that this is really in the U.S national security interest of the United States and even though some of the companies did an
2:29:102 hours, 29 minutes, 10 secondsenormous amount of classified work and provided materials to the US government so there's a whole arm of lots of these companies that do that in a in a
2:29:192 hours, 29 minutes, 19 secondsconfidential way um but if you were to tell the CEO that we're working on this because this is in the U.S national security interest they
2:29:262 hours, 29 minutes, 26 secondswill automatically run and hide because it's too controversial they don't want to be seen then you're going to go into
2:29:342 hours, 29 minutes, 34 secondsI don't know pick a country in Europe and yours oh sorry sorry you're seen as um you're seen as a tool of the U.S government
2:29:422 hours, 29 minutes, 42 secondsthat's not so comfortable what if you're going into South America you're going into Asia and you're a tool of the US government so you have to be extremely
2:29:502 hours, 29 minutes, 50 secondscareful and CEOs are nervous they want to be seen as Global they want to be seen as neutral and getting support from
2:29:572 hours, 29 minutes, 57 secondstheir home country yes but they want to be very careful about that yeah I would I think that's I think you're absolutely right I think the uh
2:30:042 hours, 30 minutes, 4 secondsthe way we phrase it is that our Economic Security is National Security and and I think some companies will recognize that you know creating jobs back at home is what this is really all
2:30:132 hours, 30 minutes, 13 secondsabout at the end of the day if we can help create uh Prosperity uh uh for ourselves and for others I think makes a big difference it's it's important uh
2:30:212 hours, 30 minutes, 21 secondsthat that we do the Outreach to bring to bring companies to bear in a national security Center an economic security sense uh two markets uh because uh
2:30:302 hours, 30 minutes, 30 secondsbecause they they do line themselves up well uh with our our national security interests in other words I I mentioned earlier that there are agencies talking
2:30:382 hours, 30 minutes, 38 secondsto us about the Ian dime uh and the the importance of of uh of understanding that where U.S companies are presence
2:30:452 hours, 30 minutes, 45 secondsare present it particularly in a big way we probably have a pretty good relationship with that country uh you know and and so we want to build upon
2:30:522 hours, 30 minutes, 52 secondsthat and I think we've lost some ground uh over the years uh in in terms of the volume and and presence of U.S business uh you know vis-a-vis others who are who
2:31:012 hours, 31 minutes, 1 secondare taking taking more advantage of these markets in showing that you know that we still are not only a a favored
2:31:082 hours, 31 minutes, 8 secondsshould be a favorite country to to work with but we have preferred uh ways of doing business and I think there's a lot of work to do but I think the the the
2:31:162 hours, 31 minutes, 16 secondsessence of of Economic Security as a part of National Security is a is an important piece it's certainly important for us to to consider uh as a government
2:31:252 hours, 31 minutes, 25 secondsuh and as a country uh I think it's an undercurrent within kabda uh in some respects it's a it's we're recognizing that the need to align ourselves in
2:31:332 hours, 31 minutes, 33 secondscertain ways that so that it makes sense uh so uh you know I think it's a we there's there's but there's a lot of work to do still yeah I like to build on
2:31:412 hours, 31 minutes, 41 secondsthat a bit because I agree that that I think if you go into a C Street you start talking about National Security there's going to be like okay I mean
2:31:502 hours, 31 minutes, 50 secondscertain you know companies yes that's their bread and butter but many others may be nervous about that it may be a case of discussing using
2:31:572 hours, 31 minutes, 57 secondsthese terms in different audiences or different different milias I think within the US government and that includes dealing with Congress
2:32:062 hours, 32 minutes, 6 secondscommercial diplomacy should be seen as part of National Security right now one of the big issues out there is access to critical materials and we use all the
2:32:142 hours, 32 minutes, 14 secondsdisruptions that came out during the covid period and how many articles are you seeing now about lithium um I mean back to your high school
2:32:232 hours, 32 minutes, 23 secondsphysics class ladies and gentlemen I mean all these stuff that's going on for Renewables for Batteries uh recycling China all of this after our policies
2:32:322 hours, 32 minutes, 32 secondstowards Africa are all involving all sorts of minerals that we you know have kind of forgotten about at the same time we're talking about building a reopening
2:32:402 hours, 32 minutes, 40 secondsminds and processing here in the country so that's a good example I think of where commercial diplomacy is National
2:32:482 hours, 32 minutes, 48 secondsSecurity Now on the other hand I think that there's this this broader case which which is what you're talking about which is what companies are doing and
2:32:562 hours, 32 minutes, 56 secondsthey're doing it for their stockholders they're doing this to make a profit they're doing it for the bottom line
2:33:032 hours, 33 minutes, 3 secondsum that's going to have a beneficial impact on our national security but if you I think if you if you talk about it that way you may start scaring
2:33:112 hours, 33 minutes, 11 secondspeople I think it's a really good point Bob and and Kathleen and and everyone about how you target The Narrative well we're
2:33:202 hours, 33 minutes, 20 secondstrying to we're all talking about narrative right now and the messaging and the momentum behind the narrative and messaging I think it's been we
2:33:282 hours, 33 minutes, 28 secondshaven't been thoughtful about how to present this case and this is what we're trying to make it we're trying to make a case here we're trying to make a case
2:33:352 hours, 33 minutes, 35 secondswith Congress and Congress is making the case and then Mayors are why it's so important for U.S business to thrive overseas and what can we do as
2:33:442 hours, 33 minutes, 44 secondsindividuals as either as government officials as private sector as trade associations to promote U.S businesses overseas and to deal with some issues
2:33:512 hours, 33 minutes, 51 secondslike Market access IPR valuations or uh even pure licensing agreements you can go on and on about why it's important
2:33:592 hours, 33 minutes, 59 secondsbut it almost is being internalized by everyone who's in playing in this field well it is a priority it's not it is an essential priority of what we're trying
2:34:082 hours, 34 minutes, 8 secondsto do I agree with you and I guess I disagree with my colleagues to the left as a CEO I talked about the importance
2:34:172 hours, 34 minutes, 17 secondsof trade I've talked about the importance of international and I talked about it as National Security and I did it proudly
2:34:262 hours, 34 minutes, 26 secondsand I did it patriotically and I think my shareholders liked it could I ask a question did you come from
2:34:352 hours, 34 minutes, 35 secondsa background that gave you that sophistication first well as an international businessman I
2:34:432 hours, 34 minutes, 43 secondsguess I did um but I think I understood PR public relations and I understood
2:34:522 hours, 34 minutes, 52 secondswhat shareholders like and what security analysts like and
2:34:592 hours, 34 minutes, 59 secondsand I think they're patriotic too and I think they understand National Security and and uh and I think
2:35:092 hours, 35 minutes, 9 secondsit's important and I think you're being too soft don't be timid don't be timid is where your message was
2:35:192 hours, 35 minutes, 19 secondsthinking about the resource issue and and obviously there's a limitations in the number of Commerce officials and State Department officials charged with
2:35:262 hours, 35 minutes, 26 secondsthis activity but I wish we could think about it if everyone in a mission was charged with this commercial diplomacy aspect resources would not be as much of
2:35:352 hours, 35 minutes, 35 secondsan issue if the political officer or the Consular officer and the deal teams at under secretary Jose Fernandez talked about that's an approach to it and I
2:35:432 hours, 35 minutes, 43 secondsthink what we're seeing is we need to inculcate a culture within all our missions overseas and internally in
2:35:502 hours, 35 minutes, 50 secondsWashington that the commercial diplomacy has to be seen as higher priority as our military security and other aspects of
2:35:582 hours, 35 minutes, 58 secondsit one of the things I'd be curious about and and you talked a little bit about critical minerals Bob um is this fast changing world of
2:36:062 hours, 36 minutes, 6 secondstechnology and critical minerals and I know um even a few years ago when somebody mentioned Huawei and going out into the
2:36:152 hours, 36 minutes, 15 secondsfield and having to talk about 5G and not really knowing what 5G was and even not knowing what U.S companies did in this field and what didn't it field how
2:36:242 hours, 36 minutes, 24 secondsdo you equip Embassy officials to keep up with the times to not just understand what IPR is
2:36:322 hours, 36 minutes, 32 secondsmost of us know what IPR is after you know many years of working but how do you deal with this fast-changing world under your feed and there was a good
2:36:392 hours, 36 minutes, 39 secondsarticle on foreign policy written by a current state department economic officer who has didn't come into a
2:36:472 hours, 36 minutes, 47 secondsprivate sectic tech company and instead you know the U.S Washington doesn't understand cryptocurrencies doesn't only see understand these new issues of the
2:36:552 hours, 36 minutes, 55 secondsday so how do we catapult knowledge to to understand what's going on in the real world
2:37:032 hours, 37 minutes, 3 secondsum I I don't so I don't have any answers but I don't know if anyone has any thoughts here about how to deal with this new world well if I I would say that you know you
2:37:112 hours, 37 minutes, 11 secondshave to talk to business you have to talk to companies you have to talk about what they're uh you know what their needs are what their desires are we talking about and the the point about
2:37:192 hours, 37 minutes, 19 secondsambassadors you know what uh what many of my colleagues would would suggest is that when companies come to us they usually come to us in the 11th Hour uh
2:37:282 hours, 37 minutes, 28 secondsyou know usually when they have a problem uh and what we need to do is we need to go out we need to pull those companies in early in the game to help them to help them compete and in part of
2:37:362 hours, 37 minutes, 36 secondsdoing that is to understand what their issues and needs and needs are uh you know Folks at embassies other sections Beyond at Econ and Commercial are really
2:37:442 hours, 37 minutes, 44 secondsbusy you know they're doing all kinds of things and and so we have to grab the attention where we can I think that uh uh that that that that technology uh
2:37:532 hours, 37 minutes, 53 secondsgiven its uh its state uh today in the in the in the environment basically in the in the in the National discussion uh is something that folks around our
2:38:022 hours, 38 minutes, 2 secondsaround the world at our embassies and consoles from ambassadors all the way through the various sections would be very much interested in learning more about and and how it affects them and
2:38:102 hours, 38 minutes, 10 secondshow they can can affect uh uh support for U.S companies in that space but it takes time it takes energy uh it takes
2:38:172 hours, 38 minutes, 17 secondstraining uh and and the more we can interlocut with with companies at all levels in the embassies the better off we're going to be but it is an energy
2:38:252 hours, 38 minutes, 25 secondsissue in terms of personal energy can I expand a little bit on the rule rule of the Ambassador
2:38:322 hours, 38 minutes, 32 secondsyou mentioned that my my wife and I endowed this
2:38:382 hours, 38 minutes, 38 secondsaward that goes to the top career Ambassador career Ambassador that does
2:38:452 hours, 38 minutes, 45 secondsthe best job of commercial advocacy we have a a search committee that
2:38:522 hours, 38 minutes, 52 secondsincludes Ambassador Sean Donnelly Ambassador Ron Newman Ambassador Tony Wayne and myself
2:38:592 hours, 38 minutes, 59 secondsand usually the either the chair is usually the under secretary or the assistant Secretary of EB
2:39:062 hours, 39 minutes, 6 secondsand we have one or two other CEOs and usually the head of XM
2:39:122 hours, 39 minutes, 12 secondsabout a six or seven person and so in the last years we have received
2:39:192 hours, 39 minutes, 19 secondsinterviews of over 100 people uh about five a year um
2:39:252 hours, 39 minutes, 25 secondsand let me give you the common traits that win the award uh and and and the award is structured
2:39:332 hours, 39 minutes, 33 secondsmore on the offense Tony Wayne's word then defense on purpose because
2:39:412 hours, 39 minutes, 41 secondswell I think we have a buy it we have we feel a biased that that uh policy issues
2:39:482 hours, 39 minutes, 48 secondsare are are easy for most career ambassadors offensive get out and help the
2:39:572 hours, 39 minutes, 57 secondsbusinessman open the doors use your contacts um you know each each of us as leaders have
2:40:072 hours, 40 minutes, 7 secondsonly so many contacts uh with the Prime Minister and and or the foreign minister or the president depending on the
2:40:162 hours, 40 minutes, 16 secondsgovernance and but the winners of this award use those contacts to help American Business make
2:40:242 hours, 40 minutes, 24 secondsthe deal by using their contacts and going in and telling the Prime Minister this is really important to our country
2:40:332 hours, 40 minutes, 33 secondsand our relationship with your country that you do this um each of the award winners have been
2:40:402 hours, 40 minutes, 40 secondsan integral part of their anchams they go to the American Chamber meetings they lead the meetings they speak at the
2:40:482 hours, 40 minutes, 48 secondsmeetings they give pep talks to the to those to those leaders um and they are good salesmen for
2:40:562 hours, 40 minutes, 56 secondsAmerica and um and so the good news is we have some great
2:41:032 hours, 41 minutes, 3 secondsambassadors out there we have some great winners and and one of the things I'm the most pleased with that seven of our
2:41:132 hours, 41 minutes, 13 secondswinners have then been either assistant secretaries under secretaries or in the
2:41:212 hours, 41 minutes, 21 secondscase of burns deputy secretary and so so the winners of this award are
2:41:282 hours, 41 minutes, 28 secondsalso being rewarded with the top jobs in the state department Tony Wayne's one of those winners by the way so
2:41:362 hours, 41 minutes, 36 secondsum yeah we have great ambassadors and but they're salesmen and and and that's I want my president
2:41:442 hours, 41 minutes, 44 secondsto be a Salesman and my secretary is a state in Commerce to be out more salesman and I'm disappointed on that
2:41:532 hours, 41 minutes, 53 secondsso I don't know if you have any questions from the floor um Ron are you going to ask us oh oh this is
2:42:012 hours, 42 minutes, 1 secondI I am going to take advantage of this Dale thank you for being here uh really appreciate it so I'm going to apologize
2:42:092 hours, 42 minutes, 9 secondsin advance because it's a little bit putting you on the spot and it's not really your function but you're the the one official representative we have
2:42:172 hours, 42 minutes, 17 secondsuh it preparing for this conference and talking about it with a whole variety of people talking about it with people
2:42:252 hours, 42 minutes, 25 secondstoday there is an undercurrent of unhappiness which is not quite being vocalized
2:42:322 hours, 42 minutes, 32 secondsbecause we're all polite and we have our diplomatic training and I will try to remain polite but
2:42:402 hours, 42 minutes, 40 secondsthe blunt fact is the top of the admit I I want to say this and give you a chance to respond but I want to say a partner so you have heard it here and can carry
2:42:492 hours, 42 minutes, 49 secondsit back as well frankly and that is the top of this Administration is not sufficiently helpful to the promotion of business
2:42:572 hours, 42 minutes, 57 secondscabinet was passed over three years ago it mandates that the president established a particular commission he
2:43:062 hours, 43 minutes, 6 secondshas not done so it mandates that the Secretary of State chair with the secretary of Commerce a
2:43:152 hours, 43 minutes, 15 secondsgroup to elevate the focus of commercial diplomacy that has not come into being yet and the
2:43:232 hours, 43 minutes, 23 secondslast one I asked one Congressional office that was highly involved in writing that legislation what the last thing was they had heard from State not
2:43:322 hours, 43 minutes, 32 secondscommerce was that state was thinking about how they would organize the commission that the law mandates and to whom they would delegate the secretaries
2:43:402 hours, 43 minutes, 40 secondsof state's Authority what this radiates and so I'm delighted to hear that all you're saying about Capital pointing
2:43:492 hours, 43 minutes, 49 secondsin the right direction or pushing in the right direction but I'm also hearing the feeling that it's a day late and a dollar short and
2:43:582 hours, 43 minutes, 58 secondsby the time the administration finally if they ever get around to actually exercise in the Mandate of the law the
2:44:052 hours, 44 minutes, 5 secondsadministration May depart and then we'll get to start all over again so I wanted partly to give you an
2:44:122 hours, 44 minutes, 12 secondsopportunity to comment but it's not entirely Fair because these are questions that relate to how the president and the secretaries of two
2:44:192 hours, 44 minutes, 19 secondsdivisions take action I wanted to put it on record though so you take it back because what I'm vocalizing is not just me this is very
2:44:282 hours, 44 minutes, 28 secondsbroadly out there in the business community that we talked to in the you know ex ambassadors in a whole lot of
2:44:372 hours, 44 minutes, 37 secondspeople and I don't want it to get lost in the need and proper need for politeness
2:44:442 hours, 44 minutes, 44 secondswhile over here so I want to give you any chance to respond recognizing that in a sense the
2:44:522 hours, 44 minutes, 52 secondsquestion goes to to other audiences no thank thank you and and certainly message a message taken and I will carry
2:45:012 hours, 45 minutes, 1 secondthat carry that back what I what I I think my I can respond in a way because it is a it is uh uh a little late uh you
2:45:102 hours, 45 minutes, 10 secondsknow it's a day late um uh might be a dollar short at the moment but but uh you know I really feel having having worked uh closely with the
2:45:172 hours, 45 minutes, 17 secondsstate department as I alluded to earlier uh working with EB on kabda and on the economic diplomacy advisor group and on
2:45:242 hours, 45 minutes, 24 secondsthe on the the additional advisory groups for U.S business that will be uh forming as well that we're almost there uh and so I think in the weeks ahead uh
2:45:322 hours, 45 minutes, 32 secondsyou're going to see uh some of that purpose that you in action that you've uh you've been missing from this uh I can't speak for uh uh for the state department uh specifically but I can
2:45:412 hours, 45 minutes, 41 secondstell you that secretary raimondo is very supportive of U.S businesses doing everything she can uh to uh to not only instill in us the importance of uh of uh
2:45:502 hours, 45 minutes, 50 secondsAdministration priorities particularly in Asia uh uh uh and uh and for things like diversity and then at other aspects
2:45:572 hours, 45 minutes, 57 secondsand technology and it's an environment we have within our strategic plans have a renewed sense of purpose and focus uh
2:46:062 hours, 46 minutes, 6 secondsfrom her priorities in doing so but I would say just bear with us a little bit longer and I'll put Commerce into the into the room on that one we're going to
2:46:142 hours, 46 minutes, 14 secondshave a uh a very good uh message to send on the importance of capital and the work that we're going to be doing together and it's coming out shortly
2:46:222 hours, 46 minutes, 22 secondsKathleen to support Ambassador Newman's comments in addition uh
2:46:292 hours, 46 minutes, 29 secondsall of his comments were reinforced by a a
2:46:362 hours, 46 minutes, 36 secondsCongressional budget office report in June of 22 basically saying the same things
2:46:432 hours, 46 minutes, 43 secondsAmbassador Newman said that it's been a long time and and it's disappointing that these actions haven't been put
2:46:522 hours, 46 minutes, 52 secondstogether so you might you might remind some of your colleagues of that Congressional budget office report of June of 22.
2:47:042 hours, 47 minutes, 4 secondsfire Court I'm not a diplomat in fact I'm known for being undiplomatic and in that vein I'll ask
2:47:132 hours, 47 minutes, 13 secondshow disruptive to our commercial diplomacy are sanctions or the threat of sanctions
2:47:242 hours, 47 minutes, 24 secondsexactly if I think if we take this at a global level I don't know that they're they're
2:47:332 hours, 47 minutes, 33 secondsthat terrifically disruptive to most of the business that most companies do in working on sanctions I think we
2:47:412 hours, 47 minutes, 41 secondstended to sort of during my time um we were focusing on Iran North Korea
2:47:512 hours, 47 minutes, 51 secondsum those are really the uh sort of the and actually at that point too because there's been a change in government in in Myanmar Burma
2:47:592 hours, 47 minutes, 59 secondswe were actually looking at tear and take sanctions off and one of the things we found is if you think it's fun putting sanctions on taking them off it
2:48:082 hours, 48 minutes, 8 secondscan be even more complicated um Burma unfortunately went back the wrong way so I'm sure my successor is to
2:48:152 hours, 48 minutes, 15 secondsput those everything we took off put back on um South Africa might be a good example of one that took things off um
2:48:232 hours, 48 minutes, 23 secondsbut you know there's still Provisions out there I mean Jackson vanic lives um in is it is a has an impact on our
2:48:312 hours, 48 minutes, 31 secondstrade with Central Asia still um now the Soviet Union's gone Central Asian countries have their human rights
2:48:402 hours, 48 minutes, 40 secondsissues but it's not what was going on against uh Jews in the Soviet Union but yet that provision is still on the books
2:48:472 hours, 48 minutes, 47 secondsand still has a impact on our trade policies um towards that part of the world so that's that's one aspect I would if
2:48:562 hours, 48 minutes, 56 secondsthere are certain things you know I think this is where the National Security piece does come in big time um Tech Industries and when you get to
2:49:032 hours, 49 minutes, 3 secondscertain levels and you know one years when they start Crossing various levels of things they can become a problem I wouldn't say necessary in terms of
2:49:112 hours, 49 minutes, 11 secondssanctions but in terms of Licensing export licensing and so forth and different administrations have taken different approaches on that I've been
2:49:182 hours, 49 minutes, 18 secondswhipsawed personally those different groups came in and went out you probably have as well Congress gets this big time
2:49:252 hours, 49 minutes, 25 secondsbut I don't I think in terms of the the general macro picture of the billions
2:49:352 hours, 49 minutes, 35 secondstrillions of dollars of U.S trade I don't know the sanctions necessarily come in and effect that much but they will affect things in particular markets
2:49:422 hours, 49 minutes, 42 secondsthey will affect things in particular sectors and I think the companies that are active in those sectors that's where the CEO knows big time what it is that's
2:49:512 hours, 49 minutes, 51 secondsgoing on on this I mean you may have a better they would pay a lot of attention to sanctions because you're blocked from a market so you have to figure a way
2:50:002 hours, 50 minutesaround or you can get in trouble because your product was made somewhere and put in down the line or resold and that is a No-No and so
2:50:082 hours, 50 minutes, 8 secondsit's really it's extremely complicated and companies frankly governments have a lot of tracking mechanisms companies are Reinventing the wheel
2:50:162 hours, 50 minutes, 16 secondsevery time to put into place a tracking mechanism it's the same it's the same problem with taking State incentives or
2:50:232 hours, 50 minutes, 23 secondsfederal incentives or XM Bank financing or developing Bank in the Asian development bank or the European
2:50:312 hours, 50 minutes, 31 secondsDevelopment Bank which has a more complicated name I've forgotten it exactly but every time you take one of those interactions with government companies have to track it they have to
2:50:392 hours, 50 minutes, 39 secondstrack all their exports and it's extremely complicated and they're not really set up for that they really don't have a an apparatus that is easily
2:50:492 hours, 50 minutes, 49 secondsaccessible to take care of all of those things and so I think that overlay that's the National Security and the foreign policy and geopolitical overlay
2:50:572 hours, 50 minutes, 57 secondsthat gets companies to cringe at the idea of let's do more investment let's try and use the government apparatus um
2:51:052 hours, 51 minutes, 5 secondsthey're nervous about it and they are nervous about sanctions but it really is a strategic small portion usually of
2:51:132 hours, 51 minutes, 13 secondswhat someone's business is it it's not whole cloth it's not a whole sector it's not a whole country except for maybe Russia Russia is Russia is I think the
2:51:222 hours, 51 minutes, 22 secondsthing the foreign but it does make it more complicated for companies and they have to think about that but that's the same level of
2:51:312 hours, 51 minutes, 31 secondssophistication that they don't always have with the foreign policy sort of aspect there's a question online which unfortunately I can't really read with
2:51:402 hours, 51 minutes, 40 secondsthe reflection um so somebody read it can someone read it for us
2:51:582 hours, 51 minutes, 58 seconds[Music]
2:52:082 hours, 52 minutes, 8 secondsUSDA Etc from Tyler washer U.S China foundation for exchange yeah you keep
2:52:162 hours, 52 minutes, 16 secondsstatistics every year how many Commerce and state do report every year of how many commercial transactions the US government uh so I you know the export
2:52:252 hours, 52 minutes, 25 secondspool of companies that actually export more than like accidentally but export on a as a part of their business plans
2:52:312 hours, 52 minutes, 31 secondsis somewhere between 250 000 to 300 000 companies in the us and we're all these small companies in particular small medium size that's pool that could be
2:52:392 hours, 52 minutes, 39 secondsgrowing it's something we need to work on but but of of a proportion of that pool um uh for example I I mentioned earlier
2:52:452 hours, 52 minutes, 45 secondsthat we last year met with and helped 51 000 uh distinct uh exporters uh in that
2:52:532 hours, 52 minutes, 53 secondsuh in that process so so that's uh you know that there's much more to do and then when you talk about resources you think about well you want to reach out
2:53:012 hours, 53 minutes, 1 secondand grab companies and bring them to markets overseas you want to reach out and tell a company Hey look it's not just about you know your your neighborhood or your state or your
2:53:092 hours, 53 minutes, 9 secondsregion it's about the world today and and and if you see a company in our U.S field offices uh you know see a lot of these companies if they see a company
2:53:172 hours, 53 minutes, 17 secondsthat really has an opportunity to export because they've got a great product they're you know Cutting Edge whatever the case might be that company may not be ready uh and and a lot of the
2:53:262 hours, 53 minutes, 26 secondschallenges the big big companies have in terms of of doing business overseas it's magnified tenfold for for a small firm and that's where we can really be
2:53:352 hours, 53 minutes, 35 secondshelpful but but finding those companies and adding to that pool is is really important so government resources the
2:53:422 hours, 53 minutes, 42 secondsmore we can do the more resources we have the more we can build that 51 000 into you know a third of the of the companies get it up to a hundred thousand or something like that
2:53:502 hours, 53 minutes, 50 secondstechnology is helpful often deal today as we know to reach out to uh uh to small medium-sized firms and Innovative firms you know they're doing it on the
2:53:582 hours, 53 minutes, 58 secondsweb they're looking for things on the web uh and uh I think that's something we're trying to tap into as well but it's about uh it's about 250 000 to 300
2:54:072 hours, 54 minutes, 7 seconds000 active exporters and we're we're getting what uh 50 50 000 of that right now would love to see that double uh we had a commitment under this
2:54:152 hours, 54 minutes, 15 secondsAdministration under secretary or Amanda to double the number of clients that we served from about 35 000 up to about seventy thousand were on track to hit
2:54:232 hours, 54 minutes, 23 secondsthat possibly this year so we're excited about that but that's with you know existing resources and so yeah we have two questions and I think we
2:54:312 hours, 54 minutes, 31 secondshave time for for maybe we'll have an asked consecutively and then we can answer together as a panel
2:54:382 hours, 54 minutes, 38 secondsokay howdy uh my name is Stephen what policy analyst with the U.S export and Port Bank uh and so since we were
2:54:452 hours, 54 minutes, 45 secondsbrought up I thought I'd come up and ask a follow-up question uh specifically when you mentioned the the satellite deal
2:54:532 hours, 54 minutes, 53 secondsum I was kind of curious in your experiences how often have y'all found that U.S companies were missing out on
2:55:012 hours, 55 minutes, 1 secondopportunities with foreign buyers because they weren't able to access export financing great and Sean
2:55:102 hours, 55 minutes, 10 secondsyeah hi thanks Kathleen um just on the on the sanctions point that was made it's more of a point than
2:55:172 hours, 55 minutes, 17 secondsa a question I think the key is is whether the sanctions that are envisioned are they unilateral or are
2:55:242 hours, 55 minutes, 24 secondsthey multilateral if if they're multilateral if you get all the major suppliers to join you in doing that
2:55:312 hours, 55 minutes, 31 secondsobviously the adverse impact on U.S business is less and I my sense is we've really made progress in that area 20 30
2:55:392 hours, 55 minutes, 39 secondsyears ago the Instinct in administrations in Congress to do sanctions unilaterally like oh something bad is going on in Zaire we're going to
2:55:472 hours, 55 minutes, 47 secondsput sanctions on them it people have learned painfully perhaps that try to get them
2:55:552 hours, 55 minutes, 55 secondsmultilateral and for many reasons to do that but one of them um site thanks so on XM and I'll turn it
2:56:032 hours, 56 minutes, 3 secondsover I can honestly say as an economic officer I never really understood what our financing capabilities were
2:56:102 hours, 56 minutes, 10 secondsum and and I think was when a real Gap in my own knowledge as a person who did economic work for 25 years and um if I
2:56:182 hours, 56 minutes, 18 secondsdon't know and then I'm assuming businesses don't know but I would turn it over to Bob you've got an example um yeah I think and actually I'm going
2:56:272 hours, 56 minutes, 27 secondsto come at this a little bit differently and this is really the sort of work I was doing subsequently to being in the department one of the problems or one I
2:56:342 hours, 56 minutes, 34 secondsmean okay on diplomatic problem realities opportunities um is that for policy reasons my
2:56:422 hours, 56 minutes, 42 secondsunderstanding XM and and DFC will do things in certain markets and up to certain levels so once you graduate to
2:56:492 hours, 56 minutes, 49 secondsyou've moved from you know emerging a market or middle economy to high income countries in the countries like Romania
2:56:562 hours, 56 minutes, 56 secondswhich are like you know go kind of go back and forth on this you know last this year there you have
2:57:032 hours, 57 minutes, 3 secondsenough money next year they may not um is that okay can we use can the company use DFC can they use XM
2:57:122 hours, 57 minutes, 12 secondsfinancing there's also various sorts of windows that are sort of being set up at different times there are things which are sort of being precluded at different
2:57:202 hours, 57 minutes, 20 secondstimes and I think right now the whole question of financing for hydrocarbon exports and how this fits in with with
2:57:282 hours, 57 minutes, 28 secondsclimate change is is something that's that's a factor um there are cleaner hydrocarbon
2:57:352 hours, 57 minutes, 35 secondstechnologies that might be good for the environment certain countries which are being precluded so this kind of thing I think becomes difficult and I think this
2:57:432 hours, 57 minutes, 43 secondsbecomes sort of I've sat down actually with with office of TDA ustda is sort of in this trade development agency is
2:57:512 hours, 57 minutes, 51 secondsanother one that gets caught in this where some of our policy some of our our policies in different areas sort of come through and have an impact on what it is
2:57:592 hours, 57 minutes, 59 secondsa U.S company can do and how they can sort of find the financing which European governments might not feel
2:58:072 hours, 58 minutes, 7 secondsquite so constrained about doing it God knows what China will feel about doing or Korea or Japan I think it goes back to the narrative
2:58:152 hours, 58 minutes, 15 secondsthat we're all trying I think we're we're not trying to create a narrative which The Narrative already exists what we have in our tools we're just not doing a good job of explaining it
2:58:242 hours, 58 minutes, 24 secondsshowcasing it leveraging it introducing it to New actors new players and I think again um as we are trying to re not Revitalize
2:58:332 hours, 58 minutes, 33 secondsI agree with commercial diplomacy is here we're doing more the momentum is behind us but we've got to move it faster quicker more urgently more
2:58:412 hours, 58 minutes, 41 secondscomprehensibly because the world is changing so quickly and I think part of it is figuring out how to tell the story more effectively
2:58:492 hours, 58 minutes, 49 secondsI know we're just about out of time um I'm going to give each everyone a final word if you want to say if if we were back here in five years
2:58:572 hours, 58 minutes, 57 secondsum what would we be saying about what a great success our commercial diplomacy is we will have had the president of the
2:59:052 hours, 59 minutes, 5 secondsUnited States lead four or five
2:59:132 hours, 59 minutes, 13 secondscommercial trade shows and and and other uh
2:59:222 hours, 59 minutes, 22 secondsevents in partnership with with other diplomatic priorities as our as
2:59:302 hours, 59 minutes, 30 secondsa French president is doing now and the Chinese president did a few weeks ago and and and other presidents of other countries
2:59:392 hours, 59 minutes, 39 secondsdo so that would be a success I would hope to see and I would like to see um
2:59:452 hours, 59 minutes, 45 secondsmore ambassadors we haven't talked too much today about how some ambassadors do
2:59:522 hours, 59 minutes, 52 secondsa great job of bringing those 22 agencies that you talked about at your one post together some ambassadors see
3:00:023 hours, 2 secondstheir job as a leadership um and and other ambassadors
3:00:093 hours, 9 secondsuh give up on the challenge of uh of trying to bring the 22 agencies together in a cohesive so I would hope to see
3:00:183 hours, 18 secondsfive years from now more ambassadors with good leadership skills that bring their whole team together on Commercial
3:00:273 hours, 27 secondsadvocacy in a better basis those are the two things I would hope nothing I I would like to see the hope that we would
3:00:343 hours, 34 secondssee the business Community put the pull aspect together pool the administration along and demand that as opposed to
3:00:423 hours, 42 secondsbeing you know sort of pulled in every now and then on a schedule could you please go with the president to something or other on Tuesday afternoon at two o'clock and they can't possibly
3:00:513 hours, 51 secondsorganize that they're they're already booked so the business Community could organize themselves to pull the administration along and so therefore the administration steps up to the plate
3:01:003 hours, 1 minuteany Administration and makes it a higher priority and to to make that happen I would say we need Dale as head of the
3:01:083 hours, 1 minute, 8 secondsforeign commercial service with all the resources that he needs Bob um I'm going to cover this with with two things one is one that I came in here
3:01:163 hours, 1 minute, 16 secondswith and that is hoping to see the private sector do more in helping educate the government not just in terms of what's going on today but what's
3:01:243 hours, 1 minute, 24 secondscoming next I think 5G was a good example when we all went scrambling and trying to barely figure out our cell phones to live on what was coming but
3:01:323 hours, 1 minute, 32 secondswhat's coming next we need to know that and our not just the top but the whole way through our our diplomatic service and that includes
3:01:413 hours, 1 minute, 41 secondsuh Commerce and and agriculture the second thing is what's come out of I think the meeting today and that is
3:01:483 hours, 1 minute, 48 secondsstrong engagement with state and local governments um in terms of what their companies are looking to do sort of getting down to
3:01:563 hours, 1 minute, 56 secondsthat level working State Department goes everywhere Commerce Department goes in the U.S we don't go in the U.S so working together on that front
3:02:043 hours, 2 minutes, 4 secondsto get a better sense of what can be done and energizing that and building on that yeah yeah I would say the the when you
3:02:123 hours, 2 minutes, 12 secondslook at the support for U.S business that we have in the US government it's kind of fractionalized it's in different bureaus it's in different departments it's in different agencies and and
3:02:203 hours, 2 minutes, 20 secondscompanies have to have to shop around and find things uh that are going to be supportive to them which is often the reason that they're late to the game and
3:02:283 hours, 2 minutes, 28 secondsin in terms of getting uh getting deals um what I would like to see uh five years from now is is something we've been battling with since I joined
3:02:373 hours, 2 minutes, 37 secondsCommerce in 1985 and that is this kind of best kept that the U.S government's support for U.S business is kind of a
3:02:443 hours, 2 minutes, 44 secondsbest kept secret uh you know companies want to compete with with each other so they sometimes don't tell each other that the US government or or the state and local governments can help you that
3:02:533 hours, 2 minutes, 53 secondsbest kept secret I think is not just that com is not just for the foreign commercial service but it's for for government in general in support of our companies I'd like to turn that around
3:03:023 hours, 3 minutes, 2 secondsin five years and see what we're seeing with uh with China and France and and the UK and others that hey look at what the Chinese government is doing for its
3:03:113 hours, 3 minutes, 11 secondscompanies look at what the french are doing for their companies I would like to see look at what America is doing for its companies but that narrative that flip in the narrative means that we
3:03:193 hours, 3 minutes, 19 secondsfinally we finally got it right well I want to thank each of the panelists for a great discussion and I'm going to turn it over to bill
3:03:263 hours, 3 minutes, 26 secondsum for final and remarks but Bill and Sean thank you
3:03:293 hours, 3 minutes, 29 seconds[Applause]
3:03:393 hours, 3 minutes, 39 secondswell thank you to the panel uh we have one more event cognizant that I'm keeping you from lunch but lunch is not quite ready so we have a little bit
3:03:473 hours, 3 minutes, 47 secondsof time uh so we're going to excuse this panel and Sean Donnelly and I are going to do a brief wrap up and then we'll
3:03:553 hours, 3 minutes, 55 secondsinvite you all to stay with us for lunch thank you
3:04:223 hours, 4 minutes, 22 seconds[Music]
3:05:153 hours, 5 minutes, 15 secondsforeign welcome back that was quick I'm here with Sean Donnelly our
3:05:223 hours, 5 minutes, 22 secondsambassador to Sri Lanka as I recall back in the day back in the day but more important he and the academy produced
3:05:313 hours, 5 minutes, 31 secondstwo significant reports on exactly the subject in 2014 and 2016. so now at with
3:05:383 hours, 5 minutes, 38 secondsthe benefit now of nine years in one case and a few other years let's start out Sean by maybe you can comment first
3:05:463 hours, 5 minutes, 46 secondson you know what do we learned today and how are things different now than they were back when you wrote that report or are your recommendations then still
3:05:543 hours, 5 minutes, 54 secondsrelevant well I think at the at the highest level not a lot has changed I think the
3:06:013 hours, 6 minutes, 1 secondrecommendations uh which we made in the two reports Chuck Ford a former director general of the FCS Ambassador in
3:06:083 hours, 6 minutes, 8 secondsHonduras was my partner in this Academy effort and we did the first report in 2015 2016 and had significant engagement
3:06:183 hours, 6 minutes, 18 secondsfrom the Obama Administration second term and they came back Commerce and state worked with us and asked us to dig down a little deeper in two or three
3:06:263 hours, 6 minutes, 26 secondsareas on training on relations between the administration and the business community and that kind of led to the
3:06:333 hours, 6 minutes, 33 secondssecond report shortly uh shortly thereafter and then as other people have said we sort of Hit the Trump Administration and frankly now the Biden
3:06:423 hours, 6 minutes, 42 secondsAdministration and have not had much luck getting senior people in the administration uh very engaged with us
3:06:493 hours, 6 minutes, 49 secondson it so I'm not sure a lot has changed I think the recommendations these are the two reports uh and uh if you picked
3:06:583 hours, 6 minutes, 58 secondsup the summary of the reports it has it has the link to the academy website where there are copies available
3:07:063 hours, 7 minutes, 6 secondselectronic copies I think they're still worth reading but I'm a little a little biased there but I think I think what we
3:07:133 hours, 7 minutes, 13 secondsheard today is the you know what's the priority the administration and administration is going to do on this what are the resources they're willing
3:07:213 hours, 7 minutes, 21 secondsto put behind it where do commercial issues fit vis-a-vis other issues human rights and and other things that you're
3:07:293 hours, 7 minutes, 29 secondspromoting so I think we're in not a very dissimilar place I want to come back to the human rights issue in a minute but first
3:07:373 hours, 7 minutes, 37 secondsum what do we need besides more money and more people right which is a common theme what else needs to happen
3:07:463 hours, 7 minutes, 46 secondswell I think it needs to be a much higher National priority Chuck Cobb says it clearly we need the White House
3:07:533 hours, 7 minutes, 53 secondsinvolvement in it I think it it does have to be a whole of government you need the defense department working with the defense contractors and so on you
3:08:023 hours, 8 minutes, 2 secondsneed the Department of Agriculture Treasury Department including at the World Bank and so on really making this a higher priority and frankly my
3:08:113 hours, 8 minutes, 11 secondsexperience 38 years in working in the U.S government if you don't have White House involvement direct involvement
3:08:193 hours, 8 minutes, 19 secondspresident and the vice president in some way it's going to get very hard to maintain the interest and the support so
3:08:273 hours, 8 minutes, 27 secondsI do think the issue at Chuck raises very graphically of having White House involvement in it and working and not
3:08:343 hours, 8 minutes, 34 secondsjust a one-time thing it's got to be a sustained effort a regular dialogue with business uh about what are the
3:08:423 hours, 8 minutes, 42 secondschallenges what are their priorities how can we take that forward is it also important for the secretaries
3:08:483 hours, 8 minutes, 48 secondsof those agencies to set the tone I mean when you were Ambassador did it matter what messages you were getting from the secretary about what your priorities
3:08:573 hours, 8 minutes, 57 secondsought to be well yeah every Ambassador gets a letter from a president as you go out and here are your priorities and it's I think what a three or four page
3:09:043 hours, 9 minutes, 4 secondsletter of the last time I saw it in commercial issues were somewhere on page two along with all the other things about values and security of citizens
3:09:133 hours, 9 minutes, 13 secondsthat are equally important I think we have to be realistic nobody's going to stop caring about anything else and would just totally do
3:09:223 hours, 9 minutes, 22 secondsa commercial uh diplomacy commercial advocacy so yeah
3:09:283 hours, 9 minutes, 28 secondsit's got to fit into an overall context I think we had a clear sense from the government this I was an ambassador of
3:09:363 hours, 9 minutes, 36 secondslate in the Clinton Administration this isn't a partisan issue but some administrations are better at it in in articulating it uh than others you
3:09:453 hours, 9 minutes, 45 secondstalked about Ron Brown he kind of not obviously especially at Commerce but I think that Spirit carried out into other
3:09:533 hours, 9 minutes, 53 secondsagencies the other thing I would just say some of Chuck talked about the ambassadors that have won the Cobb award
3:10:003 hours, 10 minutesthese are not necessarily economic career people who've done that it's the Tom pickerings and Bill Burns and Nick
3:10:083 hours, 10 minutes, 8 secondsBurns of the world these are some of our best ambassadors and they have the overall skills it's not that different
3:10:153 hours, 10 minutes, 15 secondsbeing a Salesman for policy even being a Salesman for American companies or for an american commercial interest like
3:10:223 hours, 10 minutes, 22 secondsstandards or IPR or you know getting bids evaluated on a total life cycle of
3:10:313 hours, 10 minutes, 31 secondsa project cost so these are really important things and if ambassadors get involved in it if they really are the
3:10:393 hours, 10 minutes, 39 secondschief commercial officer if they're leading the commercial team out there in those embassies it really makes a difference
3:10:473 hours, 10 minutes, 47 secondsone of the issues that came up from time to time which maybe we can go into a little bit more depth on was financing yes and the use of the export import
3:10:553 hours, 10 minutes, 55 secondsBank in particular how important is coordination with the bank which is kind of a quasi-independent agency and how
3:11:053 hours, 11 minutes, 5 secondsdid that work when you were in in this business were you able to coordinate with the bank did they reach out or were they sort of off here by themselves doing their own thing well I I had six
3:11:143 hours, 11 minutes, 14 secondsoverseas posts as the economic officer a deputy Ambassador or an ambassador and only one of them had an FCS foreign
3:11:223 hours, 11 minutes, 22 secondscommercial Service Officer there so I was mainly in poorer smaller markets developing uh countries but exim Bank
3:11:303 hours, 11 minutes, 30 secondswas a major player now early in my career I'd been the state department working level guy who went to bxm board
3:11:383 hours, 11 minutes, 38 secondsmeetings every week so I happened to personally know more about how the bank worked and who the people were and so on like that but I thought this is back in
3:11:473 hours, 11 minutes, 47 secondsthe day but I thought exim Bank did a pretty good job of staying in contact I mean my sense is that back then and I
3:11:553 hours, 11 minutes, 55 secondsbelieve it's still true today even with the enhancements at Axiom we provide official government support for
3:12:033 hours, 12 minutes, 3 secondsa smaller percentage of our exports in almost any of our competitors there are a lot of reasons for that we have a deeper private Capital Market and so on
3:12:123 hours, 12 minutes, 12 secondsbut I do think financing whether it's XM Bank the new development Finance Corporation the trade and development
3:12:193 hours, 12 minutes, 19 secondsAgency on those feasibility studies are really key and and if we're going to get serious about commercial diplomacy those
3:12:283 hours, 12 minutes, 28 secondsprograms need to be strengthened enhanced learn what works and and and so on because financing really does matter
3:12:363 hours, 12 minutes, 36 secondssome of the the growing markets are developing countries and so they're gonna they may have trouble going to the private market so I do think it's it's
3:12:433 hours, 12 minutes, 43 secondscritical I think Kathy Novelli in the first panel alluded to the difference in the potential cost difference and one of the
3:12:533 hours, 12 minutes, 53 secondsissues that I think has has been complicated for uh and you can tell me I'm wrong
3:13:003 hours, 13 minutesfor our commercial diplomacy people is to make the case convincingly that
3:13:063 hours, 13 minutes, 6 secondsquality and long-term costs matter in some respects more important than short-term Price Right does that is that
3:13:153 hours, 13 minutes, 15 secondsa selling point can we can we convince other countries that our products are not not it's not just a question though products being better in the short run
3:13:233 hours, 13 minutes, 23 secondsbut maybe ours will last longer and the life cycle issue a total Project Life Cycle uh cost and and I think that's a
3:13:323 hours, 13 minutes, 32 secondspolicy issue like IPR and standards and genetically modified products where it's not project advocacy but it's policy
3:13:413 hours, 13 minutes, 41 secondsadvocacy and Senior officials in Washington the embassies really need to be pushing that because we're very very
3:13:493 hours, 13 minutes, 49 secondsrarely going to be the low-cost supplier particularly as we compete more with with China and Korea and India as in in
3:13:583 hours, 13 minutes, 58 secondsmore and more markets it's it's not we're not where we were 30 40 years ago where you said made in America and everybody kind of instinctively said
3:14:063 hours, 14 minutes, 6 secondswell that must be the best quality I think I think we we have to keep pushing the the quality of our products we have to try
3:14:153 hours, 14 minutes, 15 secondsto be price competitive where we can't and we have to keep making the case particularly on infrastructure type projects that it's not just the initial
3:14:233 hours, 14 minutes, 23 secondssticker price it's the cost over a 25 or 30 year life cycle you mentioned one of the magic words
3:14:313 hours, 14 minutes, 31 secondsthat Matt Goodman alluded to this in his panel too which is China and he said you can't have a conversation these days without talking
3:14:393 hours, 14 minutes, 39 secondsabout that so but let's put this in the context of what both panels really discuss particularly the second one which is sort of the national security
3:14:473 hours, 14 minutes, 47 secondspolicy contact uh context and one of the things that Kathleen Ambrose said is that you know we we don't we are not
3:14:553 hours, 14 minutes, 55 secondsencouraging uh exports too or investment in China right now and that's a national security issue I
3:15:033 hours, 15 minutes, 3 secondsthink is is the question so I guess the questions are one is that right and two uh if it is right uh is that really the
3:15:123 hours, 15 minutes, 12 secondsthe policy should we we should be pursuing should commercial diplomacy be explicitly and infra an instrument of
3:15:203 hours, 15 minutes, 20 secondsU.S national security policy well I think we have to recognize that it is whether it should be or it isn't I
3:15:273 hours, 15 minutes, 27 secondsI think we are naive if we think uh that somehow all U.S policy decisions should
3:15:353 hours, 15 minutes, 35 secondsbe based on commercial interest alone and we we don't pay any attention to Human Rights or environmental impact or
3:15:423 hours, 15 minutes, 42 secondspolitical relations with the countries or so on that's going to be a factor the White House is always going to have views about which countries are key or
3:15:503 hours, 15 minutes, 50 secondswhich are supporting us on Middle East peace and that those are going to impinge on pure economic decisions I
3:15:583 hours, 15 minutes, 58 secondsthink what it comes down to is the issue we've been talking about here today how high a priority is commercial diplomacy
3:16:053 hours, 16 minutes, 5 secondsand our commercial competitiveness and interest at because it is going to every day come up against issues where other
3:16:143 hours, 16 minutes, 14 secondspolicy interests are going to be intersecting and I think many of us feel that over the long term has been a
3:16:213 hours, 16 minutes, 21 secondsgeneral sense that the commercial advocacy commercial interest commercial diplomacy hasn't been as high as it
3:16:293 hours, 16 minutes, 29 secondsshould have been but it's always going to be viewed by presidents and cabinet members and ambassadors against a backdrop of other things and so we're
3:16:373 hours, 16 minutes, 37 secondsnot going to be selling nuclear power plants to Burma or something just because it's a commercial interest there's going to be a a weighing I think
3:16:453 hours, 16 minutes, 45 secondsthe key is is commercial advocacy commercial interest are they going to have an appropriate waiting and
3:16:543 hours, 16 minutes, 54 secondsmany of us feel and I think what we've heard a lot of people here hint at today is that innocent isn't as high it hasn't had as much priority as much resources
3:17:033 hours, 17 minutes, 3 secondsas as it deserves I guess the prioritization from what you're saying I think operates in kind of two ways in
3:17:123 hours, 17 minutes, 12 secondsthe sense that one of the things the government can do is set priorities this is important this sector is important
3:17:193 hours, 17 minutes, 19 secondscritical minerals for example is important it can also set sort of negative priorities don't go there
3:17:263 hours, 17 minutes, 26 secondsyou know don't don't try to market the nuclear plant in Burma because that's not a place where we want it right
3:17:333 hours, 17 minutes, 33 secondsum let me talk for talk to us for a minute about the first one the critical minerals and and not just about minerals
3:17:423 hours, 17 minutes, 42 secondsand uh that's sort of an economic priority but what we're seeing particularly in this Administration I think is the addition of other
3:17:503 hours, 17 minutes, 50 secondspriorities to commercial relationships human rights sustainability the environment labor I
3:17:583 hours, 17 minutes, 58 secondsthink as as Chuck said this gets into overall trade policy but that's all right we can get into overall trade policy that's what we here at csis and
3:18:063 hours, 18 minutes, 6 secondsthe shulture do does this get in the way of do these things get in the way of commercial diplomacy or are they important additions
3:18:143 hours, 18 minutes, 14 secondsI think they're part of the overall Mosaic of that you have to be aware of uh and they're going to be
3:18:233 hours, 18 minutes, 23 secondscompetitions and they don't all neatly line up and say this this and this and this we're going to have to make tough
3:18:303 hours, 18 minutes, 30 secondscalls about is this is this a project that we want to go all out on and have the president you know call the the
3:18:373 hours, 18 minutes, 37 secondspresident or prime minister of the other country or is it are there other factors I mean it's policy making at the highest
3:18:453 hours, 18 minutes, 45 secondslevel is even more complicated than policy making we have done at our levels over the years I think I think but it's
3:18:523 hours, 18 minutes, 52 secondsit it's it's going to be there I I think it just keeps coming back to getting all the key players the Congress the
3:19:013 hours, 19 minutes, 1 secondadministration at the cabinet level and the White House committed that this is an important priority one of the top
3:19:083 hours, 19 minutes, 8 secondspriorities whatever and and then you gotta kind of get in there and I don't know battle is the right thing but but work to make the
3:19:173 hours, 19 minutes, 17 secondsright the best decisions you can just out of curiosity how often does the president actually call his counterpart in another country on a commercial deal
3:19:253 hours, 19 minutes, 25 secondswell people like Tony would have a sense it's it's it has happened I'm I'm aware of some cases
3:19:323 hours, 19 minutes, 32 secondseach president's a little different some liked doing it some resisted it but it it does happen it ought to happen more in my view because if you don't think
3:19:413 hours, 19 minutes, 41 secondsthat macron or the British prime minister or the Japanese prime minister or Colin or are taking groups of businessmen you don't know what's been
3:19:503 hours, 19 minutes, 50 secondsgoing on we're we're not our level of activity in the commercial
3:19:573 hours, 19 minutes, 57 secondsdiplomacy area has not kept up with what many of our competitors are doing in calls and visits in in taking
3:20:053 hours, 20 minutes, 5 secondsbusinessmen Along on important meetings well that's then uh we're running low on time let me just say if anybody has a
3:20:133 hours, 20 minutes, 13 secondsquestion for us the microphone's over there but let me talk one of the issues that we've talked about several times is kevda yes and the legislation what's
3:20:213 hours, 20 minutes, 21 secondsyour view on on implementation is that coming along is it on is it achieving
3:20:283 hours, 20 minutes, 28 secondsany I agree with Ron Newman my my friend I replaced Ron 40 some years ago as commercial officer in Senegal as I went
3:20:363 hours, 20 minutes, 36 secondsoff on my first post and he was smart dad and he's smart now I think he captured the sense that
3:20:423 hours, 20 minutes, 42 secondspeople are and I appreciate the under secretary and Dale and the efforts and I know this is hard but it's been three
3:20:513 hours, 20 minutes, 51 secondsyears and and I think people are looking looking for a little bit more what was encouraging at least to me out of cabinet is that you got you know what
3:21:013 hours, 21 minutes, 1 secondwere there three or four negative votes in the house I think it was a almost unanimous in both in both houses of
3:21:073 hours, 21 minutes, 7 secondsbipartisan commitment that this is an important priority in the administration ought to be doing more and and I I just
3:21:153 hours, 21 minutes, 15 secondshate to see that momentum from Capitol Hill get lost because the administration's been slow to to pick up
3:21:223 hours, 21 minutes, 22 secondson it and and I'm encouraged by Dale's comments that efforts are underway and and that and that's great I don't think
3:21:293 hours, 21 minutes, 29 secondsthe the the moment's been lost I just think it's it's it's critical that something happening is we're going to be into an election and then on to a new
3:21:373 hours, 21 minutes, 37 secondsAdministration or a second Administration so so yeah I think I think that the mood of the Rome on on
3:21:463 hours, 21 minutes, 46 secondskabda and what I sense to be the mood of the business community in general that you know we're a little disappointed
3:21:533 hours, 21 minutes, 53 secondsthat there isn't more real concrete progress is is is is is accurate or it's one I share okay we have an audience question sir
3:22:023 hours, 22 minutes, 2 secondsplease identify yourself my name is United States of Africa 2017 project I don't usually have a question for the
3:22:103 hours, 22 minutes, 10 secondsgroups I usually tell them what's about to happen 2025 the 54 countries in Africa will declare Songhai Federation United States
3:22:193 hours, 22 minutes, 19 secondsof Africa you should be concerned in getting in right now involving infrastructure otherwise the difficulties that are
3:22:273 hours, 22 minutes, 27 secondsevolving infrastructure develop in Africa they are the ones talking about get all the commercial activities I could I could tell you that I know I'm the one who replaced Gaddafi
3:22:363 hours, 22 minutes, 36 secondsin this project well I don't know a lot about the the detailed prospects for 2025. what I do
3:22:433 hours, 22 minutes, 43 secondsknow is Africa is a huge is a huge uh opportunity out there particularly on
3:22:503 hours, 22 minutes, 50 secondsinfrastructure and some of our competitors led by our China sorry uh are are much more active than we are out
3:22:593 hours, 22 minutes, 59 secondsthere and offering subsidized Finance now I I was an ambassador in Sri Lanka and Sri Lanka is the poster child for
3:23:073 hours, 23 minutes, 7 secondswhat happens when you get too engaged with with the Chinese and uh on their commercial loans and so on like that so
3:23:153 hours, 23 minutes, 15 secondsI would urge some of our African friends to proceed a little carefully as they jump into this but if we're not offering
3:23:223 hours, 23 minutes, 22 secondsthem from the U.S side business and government any real options governments are going to want to do something and they may make some some
3:23:303 hours, 23 minutes, 30 secondsbad decisions yes I just noticed reading this morning one of the issues that is on the table this week in another building about you
3:23:393 hours, 23 minutes, 39 secondsknow less than a mile from here in the World Bank IMF building uh buildings is a debt relief and debt relief for
3:23:473 hours, 23 minutes, 47 secondsdeveloping countries and is primarily Chinese debt yes and the Chinese have not yet indicated a willingness to forgive some of that debt and that's on
3:23:563 hours, 23 minutes, 56 secondsthe table Sri Lanka that's an example and I think a good example of of why
3:24:033 hours, 24 minutes, 3 secondscommercial diplomacy on fair and Equitable terms is important I think that's about it we I don't see other questions I don't see questions on
3:24:123 hours, 24 minutes, 12 secondsthe screen so I see food out there yeah I thank the audience for his attention I think the online audience for its attention for those of you that are here
3:24:203 hours, 24 minutes, 20 secondsplease this is a buffet style lunch the food is in the atrium please go out and get it feel free to come back here to a table and continue the conversation
3:24:293 hours, 24 minutes, 29 secondsthank you very much thank you

Continue the research

Explore the Index’s existing trade-readiness research and the questions a business can use to evaluate an international connection.

Explore trade readinessExplore business accessVisit the Media Room
My Research Workspace →